About us | Advertising | Contact | Subscribe Now! | Archive | Feedback
Jul 29, 2010 Homepage
News
Business
Columnists
Op-Ed
Arts & Culture
Weekly Almanac
Features
Travel
Life
Portrait
Women
Leisure
Sports
Cartoons
Interviews
Weird But True

Turkey in Foreign Press


Columnists
IHSAN YILMAZ ihsan.yilmaz@todayszaman.com Columnists
Kurds should not eat poisonous honey

It is wrong to argue that so many millions of Turks have been eating it, so why should Kurds not eat it, too? Nationalism is a poisonous honey, and Turks' losses as a result of eating it for the last 100 years outweigh the gains. Recent heated debates surrounding the Kurdish problem and the Turkish state's probable democratization package to tackle the problem are only recent manifestations of this reality. The Nationalist Movement Party's (MHP) harsh reaction to the democratization package sadly reminds us what our nation has lost as a result of eating the poisonous honey. But, Kurdish politicians' records so far show that Kurds, too, are also eager to eat the same honey.

Turks and Kurds are Sunni Muslims and have peacefully co-existed in Anatolia for the last 1,000 years. Interethnic marriages have always been common, and there are maybe millions of ethnically mixed Turk-Kurds in the country. More than half of the Kurds in Turkey do not live in their traditional lands of eastern Turkey but in western parts of Turkey, such as İstanbul. We have fought wars shoulder-to-shoulder, and at the Dardanelles, Turks and Kurds fell together when defending the country against imperialist powers. The problem started when Turks' common sense and wisdom were hijacked by some nationalist thinkers, and Turks decided to jettison their traditional inclusive and “ethnicity-blind” understanding of a nation. With the Young Turk Revolution, our political leaders and most of the intelligentsia succumbed to the promised sweetness of the poisonous honey and decided to give it a try, following our former subjects the Greeks, Bulgarians, Serbs and so on. There were of course some factors that forced Turks to prefer nationalism, but after 100 years of experience, one can confidently state that nationalism has not been a healthy source of food for thought. On the contrary, it seems that it has been a food for the thoughtless. It was wrong to forcefully try to assimilate Kurds and transform them into Turks.

Forty-thousand lives have been lost as a result of the fight between Turkish security forces and Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) terrorists. Some $300 billion of the nation's precious and sorely lacking funds were lost because of the fight. And, these are only calculable, direct losses. As of today, even the iron-fisted army concurs with the Turkish National Intelligence Organization (MİT) that more democracy, human rights, the first-class treatment of Kurds and socioeconomic development are the only potential cures to the problem. Last year, several retired four-star generals, including the seventh president, Kenan Evren, confessed that they were wrong to ban the Kurdish language and to try to iron out cultural differences. But, Devlet Bahçeli, the leader of the MHP, argued a few days ago that the democratization package will divide the country and the nation. This is not surprising given the fact that Turkish nationalists have never had any feeling of empathy and never thought about what they would do if their mother tongue was banned. What is more, their nationalism has always been a servant of the “sacred” Turkish state. That is why the oligarchy that has nothing to with Turkish nationalism could easily manipulate and abuse them by just whispering the magic words: in the name of the Turkish nation.

Turkish nationalists are not the only ones who have eaten the poisonous honey. Turkish Islamists have also treated themselves to the honey. If you look at the Islamist Felicity Party (SP) leaders' reactions to the Kurdish problem, the government's proposed democratization package, the Ergenekon terror organization case and civilian-military relations, you will see that they are first and foremost “sacred-state” lover nationalists and then inclusive Islamists. Kurds' Democratic Society Party (DTP) is no different. They seem to think that Kurdish nationalism is good nutrition. Instead of working toward a more democratic Turkey where everyone will be first-class citizens, they always prefer to be provocative. They deny it, but they seem to be vying for a Kurdish state. Instead of welcoming the democratization package, they ask the state to speak with Abdullah Öcalan, an offer that only provokes Turkish nationalist sentiments. Kurdish intellectual Altan Tan told us last month at the Abant Platform that there is a nice Kurdish saying: If someone does not want to throw a stone, he would stick to the heaviest stone available. It is understandable given that if he is poisoned, he would not have any energy to even lift his finger.

02.08.2009
Comments | Send to print | Send to my friend

   
Articles of Today
The new Turkey
ANDREW FINKEL
After Kosovo, where next?
AMANDA PAUL
Generals’ ‘support’ for the referendum
IHSAN YILMAZ
Mid-summer ease
MICHAEL KUSER
The globalization enigma
DOGU ERGIL

Other Articles of the Columnist

  Kurds should not eat poisonous honey
  Helping the military
  Discussing potential collaboration for global peacebuilding
  Watching the Chinese in action
  Oligarchy’s conspiracy theory versus people’s ‘conspiracy’ theory
  A final joke that will break the back of the AK Party
  United factions of the Turkish military
  Discussing sustainable development in Bosnia and Herzegovina
  What does the CHP stand for?
  A conference in potsdam
Columnists
ABDULHAMIT BILICI
ALI BULAC
ALI H. ASLAN
AMANDA PAUL
ANDREW FINKEL
ASIM ERDILEK
AYSE KARABAT
BERIL DEDEOGLU
BERK CEKTIR
BULENT KENES
BULENT KORUCU
CHARLOTTE MCPHERSON
DOGU ERGIL
EKREM DUMANLI
FATMA DISLI
FIKRET ERTAN
HASAN KANBOLAT
HUGH POPE
HUSEYIN GULERCE
IBRAHIM KALIN
IBRAHIM OZTURK
IHSAN DAGI
IHSAN YILMAZ
KERIM BALCI
KLAUS JURGENS
LALE SARIIBRAHIMOGLU
MEHMET KAMIS
MICHAEL KUSER
MUMTAZER TURKONE
MURAT YULEK
NICOLE POPE
OMER TASPINAR
PAT YALE
SAHIN ALPAY
SELCUK GULTASLI
SUAT KINIKLIOGLU
YAVUZ BAYDAR