Hollande including ‘Armenian genocide' in French textbooks
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
19 May 2013 Sunday
 
 
 
 
 
 

Hollande including ‘Armenian genocide' in French textbooks

Read Comment
30
26 August 2012 /TODAYSZAMAN.COM
French President Francois Hollande's administration has included a chapter about the 1915 mass killings of ethnic Armenians in eastern Anatolia in secondary-school textbooks -- a move that could once again upset relations with Turkey, which was hopeful about rebuilding strained ties with Paris following the election of the new president.

Turkish daily Sabah reported on Sunday that the French Education Ministry has decided to include chapters about the so-called “Armenian genocide” in history and geography books used in French secondary schools.

French students studying world history since 1910 will also read a chapter called “The Armenian Genocide.”

Hollande said last month that he will stand by a campaign pledge to make it illegal to deny that the killing of Armenians by Ottoman Turks in 1915 was genocide.

Relations between Paris and Ankara had begun to thaw after a decision in February by France's constitutional court to strike down the genocide denial law as contrary to free speech.

Turkey had canceled all economic, political and military meetings with France in December after the French parliament voted in favor of the draft law.

At a joint news conference early in July, French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius said the law was unlikely to be resurrected and Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu hailed the opening of a warmer phase in relations with France.

Armenia, backed by many historians, says about 1.5 million Armenians were killed in what is now eastern Turkey during World War I in a deliberate policy of genocide ordered by the Ottoman government.

Turkey says there was heavy loss of life on both sides during the fighting, in which Armenian partisans supported invading Russian forces. The Ottoman Empire collapsed after the war. Successive Turkish governments and the vast majority of Turks feel the charge of genocide is an insult to their nation.

Turkey hoped Hollande's election might mean France is more open to its joining the European Union than under his conservative predecessor Nicolas Sarkozy, but has so far received no public support for its EU bid from Paris.

History-Geography Teachers Council Secretary-General Hubert Tison has said the chapter in the textbooks is devoted to giving detailed information on the so-called “Armenian genocide.”

Tison criticized as “redundant” the inclusion of the chapter, which will explain in detail the genocide, ethnic structure of the Ottoman Empire, rule of Talat Pasha and policies of nationalist Turks and purported exiles. The chapter will also include the numbers of Armenians who were killed, exiled or sent to death.

Turkish Education Ministry officials said they will first need to examine the book and see if it includes phrases that incriminate Turkey and they will respond in line with international law through diplomatic channels. The officials said both countries earlier established commissions composed of experts to remove discriminatory phrases in textbooks and accused the French government of what they said is a “politically motivated” move.

 

 
COMMENTS
Turks should know their history also through the french text books, cause their turkish books are full of lies and falsification! If Turkey was honest the same would have been found long ago also in Turkish scholar text books. But Turkey prefer to lie even knowing the truth and brainwash its people....
Araratian
Until when will Turkey deny?
VTiger
@ Magdassian Your example is quite funny because you cite an unkown, marginal Professor who is not even a historian! Why don´t you tell the TZ audience that Israel, Great Britain and other countries refuse to acknowlege an Armenian Genocide? Turks committed genocide against Armenians?It is quite the...
Esat
I would like to share with the respected readers of TZ the thoughts of Stanley Cohen,Professor of Criminology,Hebrew University,Jerusalem,who in 12.01.1995 said the following,I quote,"The nearest successful example of(Collective denial)in the modern era is the 80 years of official denial by successi...
Gaidzag Magdassian
The Armenian Genocide thesis is not an accepted historical event. Only some marginal historians who are not good enough to work about the Holocaust or other relevant historical events go on for this stuff. Armenians and their friends were not able to show only one document which could prove that the...
Esat
The french decision is a crime against humanity. They invent a fake history and try to implement hate against Turks, Turkish History and Islam. But we can not only give all the blame to some french politicians. The main problem is still the Armenian Community there because they refuse dialogue about...
Esat
My Grandfater has told us many stories about what the Ottoman Turks did to not just Armenians, buth the Arabs as well, the Turks are not trusetd by the Arabs for very good reasons,Turkey plays the Islamic card when it wants to , and the plays one Arab against the other. The Arabs have not forgotton ...
Abdul
There were genocides in Sebrenica, in Karabagh, in Palestine, and all over the world, but certainly not in the Ottoman Empire, because they were all good Muslims and good Muslims cannot commit genocide, as our dear PM told us recently. That for sure settles the matter (irony off).
erol
1- The Turkish citizen Armenians side with the back then Enemy of the Turks, French and the Russians... 2- They attack the Turks and the Kurds... 3- The Allies fail to keep their promises to the Armenians and leave them to their fates 4- The Armenians fail to accept that they were traitors to the...
Na
Mr. Metin, ware women and children too THREATENING "protection" the turkish fatherland !? ALL children sacred, AS WE ALL NOT TO BE REMINDED.
sevan
what about more than one million people killed in Algeria by France, isn't that a genocide as well????
Suzi
Metin, your advice to Turkey to face eastward is a recipe for disaster. You will beconme an Islamic theocracy ruled by Islamist theocrats who strive in supressing the human rights of others in the name of Allah. I would advice Turkey to look westward. Regards
Thessalonian
What else can one expect from societies where hypocricy is a way of life !Will he include French genocide in Algeria,indo-china
kapitop
et purquios no? and why not,its part of history , Turks cannot re-write history because some none Armenians witnessed it before they were sent to Der Zor Truth is like sunlight,it may shine your path or blind your eyes. Truth shall set you FREE on this narrow road of a life Power of mind is the re...
sam
To have peace Turkey should make justice with the Kurds, Armenians and with all it's ethnic population.
Raffi
The time has come for Turkey to admit that the Ottomans conducted a mass genocide against the Armenians. The entire world says you did so why deny it??
Eli Minoff
The problem with the Armenian Genocide is that innocent elderly people along with women and children were annihilated AFTER the fightings.The crime was premeditated and organized by the state.The same happened with Greek Pontiacs, as well as with Asia Minor Greek origin population after the 1922 de...
Chris Athens
The Armenian Genocide is an accepted historical event in nearly every western nation except for Turkey. Turkey continues to live in denial about the ugly events which happened under it's governments during the early part of the past century. Those who do not confront their history are doomed to repe...
Christoph
@Davy de Verteuil, you're nauseating! France is not denying their own dark history and please, Israel is the only sane country in the entire region. Like you would not kill those that try to kill u first? Don't bother telling me that jews didn't live there forever with continuous presence in Israel ...
Agatha
Turkey's sensitivity about its pride is being exploited. By making this move, the French government has in a simple stroke set off a likely chain reaction that will lead to further drift between Turkey and the EU.
What if
Metin. You talk about the horrible things France has done in history. But you have totally missed the point. The article is not about competing which is the "historically best country". The article is about past events is presented in todays school books and how it is debated in the society. What ha...
F Oku
How are school books from other countries dealing with this? Are we going to freeze the relations with all countries which have called this "The Armenian Genocide", or are we just going to disconnect from a few of them? I can not relly see a clear policy on this issue.
F Uture
Let Turkey get upset, shame on them for continuing to distort history to their liking. Turkey isn't the only Muslim country that teaches incorrect history in their textbooks and all with the specific purpose to distort the truth and increase tensions and racism.
Cen
This is ironic coming from France, a former colony power which killed many more innocent people than Turkey did trying to defend their country during WW1. Turkey should not expect any favours from this leader either. The EU is Christian club, pure and simple. Face east Turkey, that's your place in t...
Metin
@ why?..obviously your leaders,
reality
I thought A lot of countries recognized the 'Armenian Genocide' not just Armenians and historians.
reality
Who cares?
why?
France's history in the Caribbean Asia and Africa rivals Contemporary American and Israeli history with untold undocumented grimace massacres and genocides. The Arrogance of the North Atlantic Tribes is nauseating.
Davy de Verteuil
You are really funny, TODAY's ZAMAN! On the one hand you refer to the Armenian Genocide in your story " as the so-called Armenian Genocide" while in the 8th paragraph of your story you state that "Armenia, backed by many historians, says about 1.5 million Armenians were killed in what is now east...
Hamasdegh
Genocide remains genocide whatever president is ruling in whatever country! Get it down your throat!
Mira
Click here to read all user comments
Diplomacy  Other Titles
...