Good things happen in the Middle East, too
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
21 May 2013 Tuesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 19 August 2012, Sunday 8 0 0 0
CUMALİ ÖNAL
c.onal@todayszaman.com

Good things happen in the Middle East, too

The Arab Spring proved to be a failure in Syria. President Bashar al-Assad’s regime, supported by China, Iran and Russia, still survives despite the massacres it commits.

 Assad does not care about the murder of innocent people, the risk of dividing the country or the further destabilization of the Middle East.

At the same time, Yemen is going through a difficult process: Attempts to achieve unity after the fall of Ali Abdullah Saleh have failed so far. Blood is still being spilled.

A long time will be needed before stability is achieved in Tunisia and Libya, both of which recently held free elections.

Mohamed Mursi, the first democratically elected leader of Egypt, which saw a period of collapse during the Mubarak era, is taking strong and decisive steps towards democratization and economic stability.

At a time when analysts were waiting for a grand power struggle to start in Egypt, Mursi made a surprise decision and attempted to reconfigure the army, the more powerful partner in the administration.

He issued a decree dismissing a number of high-level army commanders, including former Defense Minister Field Marshal Hussein Tantawi, who played a crucial role in the continuation of the Mubarak regime in Egypt.

Additionally, Mursi annulled the Constitutional Declaration, which had enabled the Supreme Military Council, in which these generals acted as members, to be a part of the administration. Now, Mursi is expected to purge influential figures who were close to the Mubarak regime, including former generals, intelligence and security officers, from the state apparatus.

It is crucial for the consolidation of democracy in the country for Mursi to redesign the military and security units and make them responsible for the protection of borders and national security alone. In fact, with these steps, Mursi may prove he does not need to imitate the Turkish experience to achieve success in the process of democratization.

The primary reason Turkey has been suggested as a model for Arab Spring countries is its ability to balance Islam and democracy. Unless he creates the Iranian-style democratic structure of which Egypt’s left wing, seculars and Christians are afraid, Egypt could become a stronghold for democracy in the region.

However, by some measures, Mursi also raises serious concerns. These include censorship of the media and excessive restrictions. The harsh measures imposed against the Al-Dustur daily, which attracted attention with its mostly exaggerated and sensationalist reports against Mursi and the Muslim Brotherhood, pro-government newspapers’ refusal to publish articles by certain columnists and allegations that some of the top executives in some influential papers were picked from among supporters of Muslim Brotherhood are some of the examples of Mursi’s poor record.

The greatest challenge for Mursi is the economy. Even though he is taking big steps towards democracy, if he fails in the field of the economy, Mursi will never succeed in minimizing the tension in the country. Democratization efforts will not be attractive to people if tension remains. Unless the people become rich and receive proper services, Mursi will not be able to transform the country.

Mursi, who has the support of the Muslim Brotherhood movement, which has been an influential player in providing health, schooling and other social services for many years, has to consider the demands and needs of the 75 percent of people who did not vote for him. Otherwise, domestic peace will not be achieved.

The situation in the Sinai Peninsula is a great challenge for Mursi. It is likely that the deep state, as well as Israel, may sponsor provocative incidents and attacks in this region in an attempt to undermine Mursi’s image.

In the 1990s, there were attempts in Turkey to prove that Iran was responsible for unsolved assassinations and murders in order to make the people believe that there was the threat of fundamentalist terror. In this way, the deep state was able to control the state and put pressure upon those who were religious.

A similar scenario is being staged in the Sinai Peninsula now. Through attacks obviously sponsored by Israel and the deep state, the relevant actors may want to intensify the pressure upon Egypt and make the Bedouins hostile to the system in the country. By careful steps and serious policies, the Mursi administration may address the main issues in the region. The first step of these policies and measures could be the introduction of measures and regulations towards the military and security units that are responsible for the political, social and security policies in the region.

Mursi gave initial signs that he could do this by the removal of Tantawi. Egypt, as well as its first democratically elected president, has to remain cautious and careful in order to sail safely through the dangerous waters of the Middle East.

COMMENTS
what about morsi visiting iran??? is that "good news" too??? good news will be when syria and iran are split twenty ways each...
jeevan
What good things come from the Middle East? I only read about terrorism and increasing violence. Hardly any good news come out from that region; no inventions in medicine, technology or anything, so what good things are you talking about? How about you list just 3?
Jaime
Mr. Onal, I'm embarrassed for your ignorance and blatant lies
Korhan
The statement that Israel staged the attacks in and from Sinai is a ridiculous nonsense. The author calls this "obvious"* which probably means that he imagines this or wishes to be like that. But facts are facts, and the muslim world has to look into the mirror and recognize the truth: the muslim wo...
Media watch
The attacks on Egypt by the terrorist Palestinians are sponsored by Israel???!! You're delusional and ignorant. You like to murder your own people, then turn around and point the finger at Israel. I'll read no more of your biased garbage.
Gregorious
Censorship, attacking journalists, closing newspapers, -- sounds like the Turkish model to me. Also, could it be that the tension in the Sinai is coming from Gaza, not as contended here from Israel and the so called deep state? Could it be that the Bedouins has very real long standing disputes wit...
rich
The Egyptians are crucifying Christians, literally. Terrorizing all who oppposes the Muslim brotherhood. What in the world are you talking about? Where is the outrage in Turkey?
Michael
" A similar scenario is being staged in the Sinai Peninsula now. Through attacks obviously sponsored by Israel " What a bright analysis or does Mr.CUMALİ ÖNAL is a joke-teller ?
Ben Yacob
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
19 May 2013
Why is Turkey not getting involved in Syria?
12 May 2013
What is Israel pursuing in Syria?
5 May 2013
When a terrorist becomes seen as a freedom fighter
28 April 2013
Can Turkey solve the Palestinian problem?
21 April 2013
Why would Turkey pursue a policy harmful to Egypt?
14 April 2013
Egypt on Turkey’s path
7 April 2013
Should Egypt fear Iran?
31 March 2013
Why did Israel apologize to Turkey?
24 March 2013
Streets no solution in Egypt
17 March 2013
If Muslim Brotherhood nominates liberals in parliamentary elections
10 March 2013
Could a military coup be on the horizon for Egypt?
3 March 2013
How will Egypt get out of this crisis?
17 February 2013
An Islamic Nations Security Council
10 February 2013
Has al-Qaeda been defeated in Mali?
20 January 2013
Why are Russia, Iran and China silent on Mali?
13 January 2013
New Egypt means new opportunity for Palestine
6 January 2013
Now is the real test for Morsi
30 December 2012
Does Turkey belong to Europe or the Middle East?
23 December 2012
Egyptian opposition, Turkish opposition
16 December 2012
How to read historic referendum in Egypt?
9 December 2012
Are you a supporter or opponent of Morsi?
2 December 2012
The greatest risk for Egypt: polarization
25 November 2012
Israel’s art of killing
18 November 2012
Israel likes hazy weather
11 November 2012
New closing hours for shops to change Egyptian lifestyle
4 November 2012
Qatari Emir’s Gaza show
14 October 2012
A search for alternatives to the Muslim Brotherhood
30 September 2012
Morsi and the AK Party experience
23 September 2012
Can Turkey and Egypt rebuild the Middle East?
16 September 2012
Hidden messages in the events in Libya
9 September 2012
Is Turkey losing its influence in the Middle East?
2 September 2012
Iran is trying to seduce Egypt
26 August 2012
Will Israel pursue same policy in Syria as Ethiopia’s in Somalia?
19 August 2012
Good things happen in the Middle East, too
12 August 2012
Sinai Peninsula a great test for Mursi
5 August 2012
Why do Arabs remain silent on the Kurdish issue?
29 July 2012
Does the Arab community admire Iran?
22 July 2012
Turkey: tired of high-pitched foreign policy
15 July 2012
What will Morsi do about Syria?
8 July 2012
Why should Mursi make his first visit one to Turkey?
1 July 2012
Why are the West and Israel afraid of Morsi?
24 June 2012
Egypt’s doubters
17 June 2012
Erdoğan 2002, Mursi 2012
10 June 2012
Does the Erdoğan government want Mursi to win?
3 June 2012
Egyptian voters made the most challenging choice
27 May 2012
Critical months for Egypt
20 May 2012
Is Amr Moussa really the favorite presidential candidate?
13 May 2012
Economy key for AK Party’s success, but what about for Egyptian leaders?
6 May 2012
Is Egypt aware of the danger?
29 April 2012
Egypt and the example of Turkey (1)
22 April 2012
Egypt is becoming Turkey
15 April 2012
A bitter lesson for the Muslim Brotherhood
8 April 2012
Is Khairat al-Shater Egypt’s Erdoğan?
1 April 2012
Muslim Brotherhood should seek consensus
25 March 2012
If those dealing with the crisis aren’t sincere…
18 March 2012
By launching rockets, Palestinians fall into Israel’s trap
11 March 2012
Critical three months for transition to democracy in Egypt
4 March 2012
If Syria becomes like Libya, the ME region will be singed
19 February 2012
Qatar: Impossible to understand
12 February 2012
US, Israel will not attack Iran
5 February 2012
Will the people of Egypt become divided like the people of Turkey?
29 January 2012
Will Egypt be able to achieve what Turkey achieved in 2002?
22 January 2012
The greatest danger facing Egypt: Economic crisis
15 January 2012
Leader wanted for Middle East, now!
8 January 2012
What will the West do about the Muslim Brotherhood now?
1 January 2012
Is Assad any different from Gaddafi or Mubarak?
25 December 2011
What will the Middle East be like in the next 10 years?
18 December 2011
Christians accepted in Egypt
11 December 2011
Why the insistence on calling the Arab Spring the Arab Fall?
4 December 2011
Is Turkey running out of steam in the Middle East?
27 November 2011
Egypt is going to the polls on a knife’s edge
20 November 2011
Is Turkish military source of inspiration for Egyptian army?
13 November 2011
Will the Syrian crisis be able to awaken sleeping giant Arab Union?
6 November 2011
Muslim Brotherhood did not understand Erdoğan’s message on secularism
...
Bloggers