Culture
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
22 May 2013 Wednesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 06 August 2012, Monday 2 0 0 0
ALİ BULAÇ
a.bulac@todayszaman.com

Culture

A lot has been said on the notion of culture since its emergence. The notion, coined by the Germans, still remains unclear; there is no agreement on its definition. Anthropologists give nearly 360 definitions of culture. However, despite uncertainty on how to define it, there should not be any disagreement on the functions it plays in the modern world. The Muslim world should be viewed as an exception because most Muslims believe that culture is possible and necessary and further argue that Islam represents a superior culture.

We, the Muslims, as in the import of the institutions and structures, incorporate Western concepts without paying attention their semantics and attempt to subject this notion to a process of Islamization; subsequently, we come to believe that things we have Islamized fully belong to us. Our misperception lies in our own attitude.

As opposed to being Islamized, Islamization functions as a legitimizing tool rather than a force that transcends the structures held by the Muslims eager to exhaust the culture of the modern world and transforms these structures. Of course, those who are familiar with the assertions and nature of religion admit that it interferes with the semantics of the language. Semantic intervention is the major tendency of religion. And naturally, if it is to interfere with an area, a religion does this by its followers. In other words, the active subject of the interference is the Muslim actor. However, the Muslim actor may not get results consistent with the goals of religion all the time; sometimes what it does may be possible but not legitimate.

Islamization, which the present-time Muslims resort to as a method and tool of intervention, seems to be illegitimate in this regard. The clear example of this lies in the nature of the hopeless relationship between Islam and culture. The notion of culture, because of its semantics, reference sources and major philosophical assumptions, cannot be Islamized.

In essence, culture is secular and national; in this sense, it belongs to the state. Without these two characteristics, culture of any sort cannot be designed and it cannot replace the mental coordinates of human beings.

The goal of culture is to secularize society and to provide a fertile ground for individuals so that they acquire a national formation on a secular basis as a tamed entity. The state’s survival depends on culture. The modern state that seeks to build a nation does this via culture. Secularization, which literally means separation of world from religion and the social and national environment that makes it possible, are the main reasons for the existence of modernity. The reason for existence in a religious world is different from this.

It is possible and essential that man attempts to have a relationship with nature and the universe based on his initial knowledge and acquire additional knowledge through this interaction. Our potential knowledge that we possess as a blessing from God in our creation is granted knowledge. However, the knowledge that the prophets have brought is knowledge of revelation. We acquire a third type of knowledge through our interaction with the universe based on these two types of knowledge; this is called acquired knowledge. Westerners call it culture whereas we may refer to it as insight or wisdom. The man of culture does not count the granted knowledge as a blessing and does not consider the revealed knowledge as trustworthy.

A mental attempt that seeks to culturize Islam or generate culture out of Islam could culminate in the secularization or nationalization of the religion. Technically, there is no such thing as Islamic or Christian culture, but there could be Islamic wisdom or Christian insight. Where culture takes its role, there is potential of conflict between ethnic groups because every ethnic group generates its own culture in a modern sense. The means at hand have been invented in order to identify the ends, and the methods to determine the content. We cannot reverse this, but by provoking a reverse format, we may acquire genuine and useful knowledge to redesign our lives.

Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
21 May 2013
Does secularization modernize societies? (1)
13 May 2013
If the world is not possible, then man isn't either!
6 May 2013
Testing liberal theory in practice
29 April 2013
Moral marginals
22 April 2013
Demanding rights!
15 April 2013
Authentic pluralism
8 April 2013
Higher reference
1 April 2013
Is democracy a sword of Damocles?
25 March 2013
Ways of cancelling the will of the majority
18 March 2013
Liberal contradiction
11 March 2013
What does democracy offer religion?
4 March 2013
Changing criteria for Muslims
25 February 2013
Who is testing whom?
18 February 2013
The democracy test
11 February 2013
A comparison between mosques and churches (2)
4 February 2013
A comparison between mosques and churches (1)
28 January 2013
Is non-Western modernization possible?
21 January 2013
Modernization, Westernization and secularism (1)
14 January 2013
Can religion be separated from life?
7 January 2013
Burning in fire of dissension sparked by unprincipled people
31 December 2012
Escape from chaos
24 December 2012
Lumpenization of bedouins
17 December 2012
Turkey’s Islam
10 December 2012
Reasons not to trust the EU
3 December 2012
Genius and taqwa
26 November 2012
What is ‘national’?
19 November 2012
UN must be restructured
12 November 2012
The world in the new era
5 November 2012
What about hunger strikes?
29 October 2012
What are we sacrificing?
22 October 2012
Turkish model
15 October 2012
Three models of Islam
8 October 2012
New political culture
1 October 2012
The way we perceive problems (2)
24 September 2012
The way we perceive problems (1)
17 September 2012
Global conspiracy
10 September 2012
A way out
3 September 2012
Religion in the name of what?
27 August 2012
Europe’s conscience
13 August 2012
Prayer
6 August 2012
Culture
30 July 2012
Society
23 July 2012
Tragedy of intellectuals
16 July 2012
Soroush’s fallacy
9 July 2012
Return to reason
2 July 2012
Once there was a Garaudy
25 June 2012
Founding actors of the region
18 June 2012
Some day, the West will realize
11 June 2012
Change of political name
4 June 2012
Search for a new model
28 May 2012
Islam is like a river
21 May 2012
What are the media? What do they do?
14 May 2012
Does anybody really know?
7 May 2012
On the army
30 April 2012
The political destiny of the Middle East
23 April 2012
The Middle East: tribe, spoils and faith
19 April 2012
Reading change (2)
16 April 2012
Reading change (1)
9 April 2012
Pluralism within Islam
5 April 2012
A single standard
2 April 2012
Religion and politics in Turkey (2)
29 March 2012
Religion and politics in Turkey (1)
26 March 2012
A new authority
26 March 2012
A new authority
22 March 2012
Philosophy of reforms (2)
19 March 2012
Philosophy of reforms (1)
15 March 2012
Handling the modernity crisis
12 March 2012
Democratization of education
8 March 2012
What is wisdom and purpose?
5 March 2012
Finding what we have lost
1 March 2012
Those who migrate, those who force others to migrate
27 February 2012
A challenging solution for Syria
24 February 2012
From Alparslan to Salahuddin!
16 February 2012
How does Iran get stronger?
13 February 2012
The state on target: Iran
9 February 2012
Sunni-Shiite-secular
6 February 2012
Wars of religion
2 February 2012
Sectarian wars
30 January 2012
The ‘other’ and our need to be ‘threatened’
26 January 2012
Salvation, not welfare
23 January 2012
Modern meaning of history
19 January 2012
Rational basis of religious violence
16 January 2012
Righteous reason and a pure disposition
12 January 2012
Enlightenment, Islam and intellect
9 January 2012
Controversy within Europe
5 January 2012
Could Christianity transform?
2 January 2012
Return to Christianity
29 December 2011
Reminding Europe of its identity
26 December 2011
Social gender
22 December 2011
NATO and Afghanistan
15 December 2011
Cause of the problem
12 December 2011
Two steps forward, one step back
8 December 2011
Thought crime
5 December 2011
Point of reference for our rights and freedoms
1 December 2011
Mistakes in Syria
28 November 2011
Concerns over Syria
24 November 2011
The single article of the Constitution
21 November 2011
There is a message for us!
17 November 2011
Human sin
14 November 2011
Lessons from the Prophet Jonah who left Nineveh
...