Let’s send all Kurds to prison
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
19 June 2013 Wednesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 14 June 2012, Thursday 19 0 0 0
ORHAN KEMAL CENGİZ
o.cengiz@todayszaman.com

Let’s send all Kurds to prison

First, we need to read the news coverage and I will explain its source and give other details later:

“Amid intense operations against the KCK [Kurdistan Communities Union], the alleged urban organization of the terror organization PKK [Kurdistan Workers’ Party], the KCK broke its silence when the number of arrests reached an unusually high level. A KCK official, speaking on unanimity, recalled that nearly 7,000 members were arrested in the operations. He added: ‘Now we see that 7,000 people were arrested as KCK members. But our records show that we have 300-500 members at most. Believe me, we do not understand when these people joined us.’

“A high-level KCK official who noted that they suspected their organization had lost control at some point said: ‘Now these KCK arrests have started; we thought it would not last long and be over in three to four operations. In the end, the organizational scheme is out there; the members of our organization are all known; we thought that our members would fill only two buses. But then we realized that we do have thousands of members. We have a young boy in our headquarters who keeps the books and records of the organization. I asked him why he has not kept records of these members. The kid has no idea. But I would like to announce that we have initiated an inquiry to address this and we will find out who is responsible for the mix-up.’

“The KCK official, noting that they are actually pleased with having people from different backgrounds and professions as members, also said: ‘I do not know how we have come this far. The organization has grown to include academics, writers, journalists and lawyers. For instance, I personally do not know, but the interior minister has announced that we have performance artists as members. Of course it would have been better if we had been informed about it, but I am still proud to serve as an administrator in such a large organization.’

“At the end of his statement, he addressed the members of the organization who he has not yet met, saying: ‘Look! Come to us before it is too late to discuss who you are and what you are doing for us. We will not know that you exist unless you get arrested. We believe that someday all will become KCK members’.”

This is in fact fake news from a web group called Zaytung, which produces black humor and satire about political developments in Turkey. I think the way they prepared this news explains very well what is really going on in the KCK case in Turkey. There is no doubt that the KCK is an illegal organization, it resorts to violence and uses terrorist methods. However, every day our police arrest thousands and thousands of Kurds in connection with this organization. In just one month, hundreds upon hundreds of people were put in prison for their alleged membership in the KCK. They are lawyers, medical students, intellectuals, mayors, politicians and so on. Zaytung is making brilliant satire out of this weird situation by referring to a so-called KCK official who seems to be very surprised to realize that they have so many members.

We have terrible anti-terror laws that have very vague definitions about being a member of a terrorist organization, acting on behalf of it, making propaganda for it and so on. These terribly vague provisions of these laws are also interpreted in such a terribly poor way by our courts, and we have so many people in prison, especially in the case of the KCK. Aysel Tuğluk, a member of Parliament, has received a 14.5-year prison sentence for speeches she made on various occasions in a number of different places. The court punished her for her support of the KCK and PKK. I have difficulty in finding the appropriate words for this outrageous prison sentence.

We should get rid of our Counterterrorism Law (TMK) as soon as possible. We really do not need it. We have the Turkish Penal Code (TCK), which has relevant articles and definitions of all crimes covered by the TMK. Getting rid of the TMK is not enough. Our judges and prosecutors need serious education on the meaning and scope of freedom of expression. They really need to understand that unless someone provokes people to violence in very concrete terms or producing hate speech towards vulnerable groups, no one should be punished for their words. The judiciary and police are not solving the terrorism problem; with all this fuss, they are just feeding it!

COMMENTS
@bagrationi,muslim kurds deported from armenia in world war 1 and late 1980s.Only Burukan clan in Van has tens of thousands of members and they are the one of the clan came from Armenia to Van.Yezidi kurds have not political demand and they didnot uprise in armenia in contrast to Turkey, so comparin...
ali38
To "ali":..where did you read that Kurds were deported from Armenia(??) The Kurdish population swelled from 40,000 (2003) to 64,000 (2011). Armenia is the ONLY country in the Middle East and the South Caucasus where Kurdish people live in relative peace and harmony and have their numbers increased. ...
Preston Bagrationi
As long as pkk attack their supporters will be punished.Turkey should make pkk supporters living dificult in Turkey by economic pressure.Kurds are not crying after they were deported from armenia and they will not cry after one generation when they deported from Turkey to their homeland of zagros mo...
ali
Orhan Kemal-bey, you are a voice of sanity. Guilt-by-ethnicity has been the cause of Turkey's greatest evils.
Kevin
i'm happily surprised to see your understanding. sentencing people to prisons for years because of words and speeches an individual made is just unbelievable. I can not understand why these harsh unimaginable laws still exist. harsh laws like that cause a huge damage and makes the gap wider and more...
Kurdish Peacemaker
Praising PKK/KCK terrorism is what is called provoking violence. That is not free speech.
Deniz
If Greece or Cyprus or any other state that is hyprocritical about Human values and being a member of the EU, then Turkey can surely be the same. I think this article clearly shows Turkey is in the same league as Britain, Germany, France, Belgium, all who supported Dictators, rendition, colonization...
Senol
Dear Mr.Cengis,I have always admired your couragious remarks on Human Rights abuses in present day Turkey.Your writings should encourage others to follow your example morally protecting vulnarable groups such as Armenians,Kurds as well as other minority religious groups.
Gaidzag
They already are all in prison, one great big open prison called 'anatolia'. Today the model of 'muslim democracy' put a deaf, illiterate Kurd who can't speak on trial for potentially 25 years on charges of terrorism. The evidence.......a lemon. You can't even make this stuff up. Lunacy!
Mountain Turks R Us
"That whenever any form of government becomes destructive ........it is the right of the people to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their safety and ha...
David
Sending all Kurds to prison is not as far fetched as deporting and killing all Armenians,Greeks and assirians as one look at history will tell that it actually happened. It will just be normal operating procedures for Turkey. The title is not as controversial as was intended.
Uncle Billy
Not so sure whether or not the title is humorous or tragic as anything goes in Turkey... Regards
Thessalonian
Excellent article. What will it take to move Turkey forward and away from repressive legislature to where all minority groups can be part of a cohesive and equally represented population. Listen to the Kurdish concerns, redeploy the "freedom fighters" into community upliftment projects. Hunger, po...
Petra
when unjust become a law the resistance bcome juty. long live kurdistan
london kurd
Great humor by Zaytung. How can Turkey dare think itself as European with such laws in place? Good enough for a Muslim "democracy" perhaps, but European?
Antifon
Could somebody find the total number of Kurds in Turkish prisons for expressing their opinion on Kurdish independence.
Babeouf
Within the context of your final sentence, I think it is very likely that the prosecutors affiliated with a certain movement are threatening AKP by pushing Kurdish electorate towards BDP.
Ferhat B
In Turkish Courts, anybody who promotes Kurdish rights-however peacefully or democratically-is likely to be sentenced for being a terrorist. Freedom of Speech in Turkey is a matter of opinion-and the Courts have the last say. It's appalling, really.
Christoph
What an awful,inhumane state [and society!]. We DON'T want it in Europe... there's something terribly wrong with the national pshyche... simply read the many social surveys!
Selena
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
18 June 2013
How did an international conspiracy manipulate Gezi Park events?
13 June 2013
Democracy at stake
11 June 2013
How Erdoğan sees all this
6 June 2013
What did prime minister's hometown tell us?
4 June 2013
Can the damage Erdoğan caused be repaired?
31 May 2013
Alevis' feeling of otherness deepens
28 May 2013
‘Satanic Verses,' Fazıl Say and Sevan Nişanyan
23 May 2013
Some citizens more equal than others
21 May 2013
Religious freedom problems in Turkey in 2012 and forever
16 May 2013
Who are the owners of places of worship in Turkey?
14 May 2013
How and why was the terrorist attack in Reyhanlı censored?
9 May 2013
The day after the PKK's withdrawal
7 May 2013
When will official reaction to 1915 change?
2 May 2013
Peace or democracy?
30 April 2013
Rumi, Buddha and remarks of Tokyo governor
25 April 2013
April 24 and Turkey's time tunnel
23 April 2013
An Armenian lady, Hrant and April 24
18 April 2013
Wise people's contribution to peace process
16 April 2013
What is wrong with Fazıl Say's punishment?
11 April 2013
How do Turkish laws produce terrorists?
9 April 2013
Truth and reconciliation commissions are necessary in Turkey
4 April 2013
What should wise people do for the peace process?
3 April 2013
Why can we not make fundamental improvements for non-Muslims?
28 March 2013
Murder of an Armenian Turkish soldier accidentally on purpose
26 March 2013
What is Turkey's roadmap for the Kurdish question?
21 March 2013
Real injustice in Ergenekon and Balyoz cases
19 March 2013
What did the Hasan Cemal case show us?
14 March 2013
Turkey, Israel and jujitsu lessons
12 March 2013
Secrecy in the investigation of attacks on Armenian women
7 March 2013
The peace process and freedom of the press
5 March 2013
Does an Armenian murderer eliminate the hate crimes presumption?
28 February 2013
Culture of lynching: dealing with hate crimes
26 February 2013
Öcalan's letters
21 February 2013
Turkey in mirror of European Court of Human Rights
19 February 2013
Victory and defeat
12 February 2013
What is wrong and right in criticisms against American ambassador
7 February 2013
Turkey's judiciary problem
5 February 2013
Hrant and Talat Pasha
31 January 2013
Genocide through the eyes of a child
29 January 2013
The Halki Theological School and the SCO
28 January 2013
‘I wish I wasn't Armenian'
22 January 2013
Why were the lawyers arrested?
17 January 2013
Is the Hrant Dink murder being resolved?
15 January 2013
Aren't the murders of Armenian women hate crimes?
10 January 2013
Atrocities in Syria committed by all sides
8 January 2013
A country of speed readers
7 January 2013
How can we achieve peace?
1 January 2013
The prime minister’s lawsuits will backfire
27 December 2012
Uludere massacre one year later
25 December 2012
Why was the commemoration for the Maraş massacre banned?
20 December 2012
How the Uludere massacre alienated Kurds from Turkey
18 December 2012
What can propaganda achieve?
13 December 2012
Praising Hrant Dink's murder
11 December 2012
Special Warfare and Christians
6 December 2012
Hrant, embarrassment, a disaster
4 December 2012
Déjà vu -- removing immunity of Kurdish MPs?
29 November 2012
Revealing too much: info belonging to Armenian groups online
28 November 2012
Turkey and Germany’s past atrocities
22 November 2012
Can Germany be a model for Turkey in confrontation with past atrocities?
20 November 2012
Hunger strikers did not die, but handicapped for life
15 November 2012
İstanbul and Constantinople
8 November 2012
Polar bears, Bedouins and poor Turkish politics
6 November 2012
Hunger strikes and a vicious circle
1 November 2012
1915: heroes and murderers
30 October 2012
The price of no criticism for the government
23 October 2012
Do not interfere with Kemalists’ mourning
18 October 2012
Armenians and a Turk in a Lebanese restaurant
16 October 2012
Restorative guilt and the Kurdish question
12 October 2012
Linking women’s stories in Turkey and Armenia
11 October 2012
1915 and terrorists on mountains
4 October 2012
The price for denial of the events of 1915
2 October 2012
How can Turkey bring an end to violence in Kurdish question
27 September 2012
Why are they so successful in seeing problematic aspects in coup cases?
20 September 2012
How Alevi victims became criminal offenders
18 September 2012
Islamophobia and hate speech in Turkey
13 September 2012
Criticizing Israel and insulting the Prophet
11 September 2012
Owen, Cemal and 1915
6 September 2012
How missionaries were linked to the PKK
4 September 2012
Will justice be served in Malatya massacre case?
30 August 2012
Campaign against violence
28 August 2012
Has the dispossessing of non-Muslims ended?
23 August 2012
Was Atatürk an Armenian?
21 August 2012
Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar!
16 August 2012
Zero tolerance for freedom of expression
14 August 2012
PKK, kidnapping and absolute impunity for the PKK
9 August 2012
Is there any ‘legal' place of worship for Alevis in Turkey?
7 August 2012
The government as an advocate of military coups
19 July 2012
The future of the deep state
17 July 2012
One basketball for all non-Muslims
12 July 2012
How was a monastery robbed in Turkey?
10 July 2012
Halki Seminary, cemevi in Parliament
3 July 2012
Who ordered the murder of Christians?
28 June 2012
From the September 1955 pogroms to a campaign against missionaries
26 June 2012
Recognizing the victimhood of the slain Christians
21 June 2012
What does the PKK really want?
19 June 2012
Prison SOS
14 June 2012
Let’s send all Kurds to prison
12 June 2012
From stone throwing children to child soldiers
7 June 2012
What do Islamist feminists say about abortion?
5 June 2012
Nationalists, muslims and the Kurdish question
...
Bloggers