RISS and Rostov-on-Don
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
26 May 2013 Sunday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 11 June 2012, Monday 1 0 0 0
HASAN KANBOLAT
h.kanbolat@todayszaman.com

RISS and Rostov-on-Don

I am in Rostov-on-Don at the invitation of Russia’s Institute for Strategic Studies (RISS), which is the official think tank of the Presidency of the Russian Federation. It is led by Leonid Reshetnikov, who is an experienced general with a good command of international developments. He loves Russia and his grandchildren. He sincerely believes that Russia should improve its relations with Turkey.

Rostov-on-Don is located at the northwestern end of the Black Sea. It is a Black Sea city that sports a Mediterranean climate and culture. It is prosperous city with a history of trade. The distance between Rostov-on-Don and Moscow is one hour and a half. It takes a two-hour flight from İstanbul to reach the city and there are four direct flights per week from İstanbul. The Don River flows through the city. This river is considered one of the border-setting natural landmarks. So the land west of the Don River is Europe and the land east of it is Asia. The Don River was also used to delineate the northern borders of the Ottoman Empire. The Ottoman forces came up to the European side of the river and considered it a border. This region is home to Don Cossacks. Cossacks also are partially descended from Kipchak Turks. The name of their first leader, or “Ataman,” was Sarı (Yellow) Azman (1548-1550). Don and Kuban Cossacks played a great role in bringing the Northwest Caucasus under the domination of Czarist Russia. But, later, they sided with Czar against Bolsheviks, and with the establishment of the Soviet Union, Bolsheviks uprooted them. And Cossacks sought refuge in their old enemy, the Ottoman Empire. With Vladimir Putin at the helm of Russia, there are efforts to revive the Cossack culture. There are efforts to make Cossack culture a driving force in the state and the popular culture.

The first Cossack capital in 1644 was Cherkassk (now Starocherkasskaya). Cossacks conquered the Ottoman Fortress of Azov in 1637. But they had to abandon it four years later, and they took the gate of the fortress and the giant fortress balance to the garden of the cathedral in Cherkassk. The gate and the balance are still there. The cathedral’s garden also features the bust of the famous Cossack general of the army of Czarist Russia, Matvei Ivanovich Platov, who was one of the Russian generals who defeated Napoleon Bonaparte. Legend has it that Napoleon said, “I would conquer the world, if there were 100,000 Cossacks in my army.” And in response, Platov said to Napoleon, “Gave me 100,000 French girls and I’ll give you 100,000 Cossacks in return.” Platov was both a good commander and a womanizer. He had returned to Russia accompanied by a young and beautiful British girl from his visit to Britain. This girl was his last wife. 2012 is the 200th anniversary of Napoleon’s campaign against Russia. During the 100th anniversary festivities in 1912, the name of the pastry “mille-feuille” was changed to “Napoleon” in Russia. Russians are very skilled in making mille-feuille.

The Don is river of great force, but it flows slowly and quietly. For this reason, Cossacks call it “Tihiy Don,” meaning “slowly flowing Don.” The name of Mikhail Sholokhov’s famous work about Don Cossacks is therefore “Tikhii Don” (“And Quiet Flows the Don”). People from North Caucasus had inhabited the Don region, known as black lands due to their fertility, before Cossacks and Russians came: Adyghas, Nogays, Ossetians... Ossetians believe that the name of the Don River is derived from Ossetian. “Don” means “river” in Ossetian. Indeed, the other rivers flowing to the Black Sea are prefixed by “din”: Dniestr, Dniepr, Danube...

Some Russian historians say, “Czarist Russia was a Slavic state with a Turkish culture while the Ottoman Empire was a Turkish state with a Slavic culture.” Indeed, the fate of the north of Eurasia was set by Czarist Russia and its successor, the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR) -- St. Petersburg and Moscow -- while the fate of the south of Eurasia was set by the Eastern Roman Empire and its successor, the Ottoman Empire -- İstanbul. The peoples who bridged across Eurasia were Romans, Russians, Turks, Iranians, Mongols, Arabs and Alexander the Great and the Macedonians. The strong administrative structures of these peoples brought stability and security to the region. Stability ensured the smooth stream of trade from the east to the west. And trade in turn boosted welfare and scientific and cultural development. These achievements were lost due to the Balkanization of the region. Turkish-Russian relations are gradually improving. The repair of the damage done to relations during the conflict between Czarist Russia and the Ottoman Empire as well as during the Cold War era is still going on. It seems authorities from both sides have focused on saving the day instead of rehabilitating the past’s wounds. The roof of a house is repaired when it is sunny, not when it is windy.

Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
26 May 2013
Analyzing Reyhanlı as a Reyhanlı resident
20 May 2013
Revisiting Russian-Circassian relations from the perspective of Russian-Turkish rapprochement
13 May 2013
Understanding Reyhanlı via my family
6 May 2013
Afghanization of Syria; Pakistanization of the ME, Central Asia and EU
29 April 2013
Putin's Kyrgyzstan visits
22 April 2013
Will the US give Central Asia to Russia as a gift?
15 April 2013
Impressions from Washington, D.C.
8 April 2013
PM Erdoğan to head off to Kyrgyzstan, Mongolia
1 April 2013
Spring festivals
25 March 2013
What will happen in Uzbekistan?
18 March 2013
The new pope and the alliance of civilizations
11 March 2013
Encouraging the growth and development of Turkish think tanks
4 March 2013
After Barzani's visit to Moscow
25 February 2013
Alliance of Civilizations in Vienna
18 February 2013
Prime Minister Erdoğan and Turkish think tanks
11 February 2013
Muslim Brotherhood back in Iraq
4 February 2013
DHKP/C in a pot of honey
28 January 2013
Israel
21 January 2013
A presidential era of music
14 January 2013
Turkey's African initiative
7 January 2013
Moscow-backed Iranian plan announced in Damascus
31 December 2012
What can we expect to happen in Turkey and its environs in 2013?
24 December 2012
Post-Jalal Talabani era
17 December 2012
Attempts by Syrian Turkmens to unite and organize
10 December 2012
Underrated visit to Ankara by Turkmen of Arbil
3 December 2012
The ÜDİK dimension of Turkish-Russian relations
26 November 2012
Barzani to Moscow, Putin to Ankara
19 November 2012
Syrian Circassians have begun to arrive in Turkey
12 November 2012
Moldova’s Gagauz people and identity issues
5 November 2012
Positive steps in Turkish-Moldovan relations
29 October 2012
Mavi Marmara trial to begin on Nov. 6
22 October 2012
Turkey’s revised Syria policy
15 October 2012
War lobbies
8 October 2012
Turkey and Syria: Is war necessary?
1 October 2012
Yannis’s Mytilene
25 September 2012
Putin’s visit to Bishkek: Central Asia, the US, China and Turkey
17 September 2012
Future concerns of the Iraqi Turkmen people
10 September 2012
Observations on Syria from Hatay’s Vakıflı village
3 September 2012
Reflections and perceptions of Russia and Russians in Turkish
27 August 2012
Why little girls don’t collect napkins anymore
13 August 2012
Observations on Syria from Hatay-Samandağı
6 August 2012
Spending time with the Free Syrian Army in Hatay’s Reyhanlı district
30 July 2012
Observations on Syria at Cilvegözü border gate
24 July 2012
The way foreignness is perceived in Turkish
23 July 2012
Uneventful days on Reyhanlı-Idlib border
22 July 2012
Looking at Syria from Hatay-Reyhanlı
16 July 2012
Prime Minister Erdoğan in Moscow
15 July 2012
Iraqi Circassians
9 July 2012
Looking at the geopolitics of the Black Sea from Trabzon
25 June 2012
BSEC Summit in İstanbul
18 June 2012
Talking with Taqi al-Mawla about relations between Turkey and Iraq
11 June 2012
RISS and Rostov-on-Don
6 June 2012
First open conference in history of MİT
4 June 2012
Kyrgyz prime minister’s delayed visit to Turkey
3 June 2012
Turkey’s Somalia strategy
28 May 2012
Second International Somalia Conference: end of transitional phase
25 May 2012
Are Russian tourists being discouraged from visiting Turkey?
21 May 2012
Growing importance of energy between Ankara and Arbil
16 May 2012
Prime Minister Erdoğan heads for Kazakhstan
14 May 2012
Turks need new strategies
7 May 2012
The results of the Greek and Armenian elections and Turkey
4 May 2012
Looking from Mosul to Turkey
1 May 2012
Al Nujaifi: Turkey is Mosul’s gate to the world
30 April 2012
Investing in Mosul means investing in the future
27 April 2012
Al Nujaifi: Turkey is Mosul's gate to the world
23 April 2012
Syrian Kurds and Turkey
20 April 2012
Syria: Towards a manageable chaos
16 April 2012
The safe zone discussion in the Syrian issue
11 April 2012
Turkey and political transformation in Middle East
9 April 2012
Syrian Kurds
2 April 2012
The future of Syria in the aftermath of Baghdad and İstanbul meetings
26 March 2012
Syrian Circassians
26 March 2012
Syrian Circassians
19 March 2012
Syrian Turkmen
12 March 2012
Analysis of placards at Khojaly commemorations
5 March 2012
Baku’s view of the Middle East and Turkey
2 March 2012
Turkmen president’s visit to Turkey
23 February 2012
Understanding Syria from Syria: Assad has six months left
20 February 2012
We discussed the Middle East at the Valdai forum
13 February 2012
Reasons for Russia’s current Syria policy and the likelihood of change
6 February 2012
Possibility of Israeli attack on Iran on the rise
30 January 2012
Maliki’s new steps that escalate tension
27 January 2012
Turkey and Russia: heading towards strong multi-dimensional and multi-directional cooperation
23 January 2012
Davutoğlu in Moscow: new era in Turkish-Russian relations
20 January 2012
Attack on Turkish embassy in Baghdad: from tension to crisis
17 January 2012
Only a step toward democracy in Kazakhstan
10 January 2012
Saudi Arabia’s new generation visits Ankara
9 January 2012
Kyrgyzstan’s new President Atambayev to visit Ankara
6 January 2012
Behind the scenes of Uludere
2 January 2012
Turkey is being forced into isolation
26 December 2011
Turkish citizenship for Armenian diaspora
28 November 2011
The future of Kazakhstan for Turkey
20 November 2011
Turkmenistan marks 20th anniversary of its independence
14 November 2011
Kyrgyzstan chooses stability: Atambayev elected president
1 November 2011
Scenarios of transition from Turkish republic to Kurdish republic (2)
24 October 2011
Turkey-Azerbaijan High Level Strategic Cooperation Council
21 October 2011
Scenarios of transition from Turkish Republic to Kurdish Republic (1)
17 October 2011
Cooperation Council of Turkic Speaking States summit
10 October 2011
Quiet developments in Turkish-Vietnamese relations
3 October 2011
Economic relations between Turkey and Syria
...