A hothouse atmosphere
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
19 June 2013 Wednesday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 21 May 2012, Monday 4 0 0 0
NICOLE POPE
n.pope@todayszaman.com

A hothouse atmosphere

It hits me every time I return from a spell abroad. The moment I step foot on Turkish soil and catch up with the local news headlines, I feel plunged into a hot bath of domestic issues that sticks to the skin like the humidity of a hamam, somehow obscuring developments in the rest of the world.

There is of course no shortage of important events to cover in this country, particularly at a time when significant changes are taking place, good and bad, that are generating plenty of controversy. Nor is it unusual for national newspapers anywhere in the world to prioritize coverage of news items deemed of local interest.

Global uncertainty has accentuated this tendency all over the world. People tend to cling to what they know and the apparent security that a familiar environment offers. Budget cuts at media organizations worldwide have also limited coverage of international events and turned the focus to local news.

But, in Turkey, this trend seems to take on an added dimension. In spite of its raised international profile and the weight it now carries on the global scene, this country remains surprisingly insular. The front pages of Turkish newspapers reflect little of the momentous challenges the world is grappling with at the moment. Few items that are not directly linked to Turkish domestic issues make it to the headlines.

If you relied on Turkish front pages to get a broad idea of what was going on in the world, you wouldn’t really understand the extent of the turmoil in Greece, nor the fact that the euro is teetering on the brink, with possible dire consequences for the world economy. The rift rapidly developing in Europe between Germany’s Angela Merkel, determined to focus on austerity and increasingly isolated, and a rapidly growing camp, strengthened by François Hollande’s election to the French presidency, advocating a focus on growth and job creation, has also been underplayed.

Regarding the NATO summit in Chicago, where leaders discussed an exit strategy for Afghanistan against a backdrop of brutally repressed demonstrations, Turkish papers mainly reported the fact that several Turkish generals were given additional stars, which would increase their and their country’s influence within the western alliance. President Abdullah Gül’s meeting with Turkish basketball players and his wife Hayrünissa’s encounter with US First Lady Michelle Obama featured higher on the agenda than analyses of the international events world leaders had traveled to the US to attend, whether it was the G8 summit at Camp David or the NATO meeting in Chicago.

With football in turmoil, a chronic Kurdish problem, a dysfunctional judiciary and a new constitution in the making, domestic issues abound that keep news editors busy. Yet at what point does this heavy concentration on local news turn into unhealthy navel-gazing?

The reaction to a recent Wall Street Journal article on the Uludere tragedy is a case in point. The article used the accidental -- and so far unexplained -- killing of 34 smugglers on Dec. 28, 2011, as an illustration of the risks posed by a US policy that allows intelligence gathered by drones to be passed on to allies without control over the way it will be used.

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan chose to deflect the debate by seeing the article as an attempt to thwart US President Barack Obama’s re-election. One editor accused journalists who had given ample play to the WSJ revelations of lacking “patriotism” on the grounds that the article could only have been planted by neo-cons to put pressure on Turkey. If people are still demanding answers about the egregious Uludere incident, it is not due to an international plot, but because the government has failed to provide explanations and call those responsible to account.

At times, one can’t help but wonder to what extent the inward focus and the temptation to view conspiracies around every corner contribute to creating the hothouse atmosphere in this country, which prevents issues from being voiced and allows them to fester. In the suffocating heat, too many events turn into damaging crises. A step back to gain global perspective and more emotional distance would put a different face on many of the issues that divide Turkish society. Sometimes it’s a case of not seeing the forest for the trees.

COMMENTS
wildTurkey, Turkiye's media is poor in its own way just like the US media is poor in it's own way. For example, the Turkish media is overly anti-Turkish and anti-Muslim while the US media is way too pro-American and way too pro-christian. I guess in that sense you could say the Turkish media is mo...
GeneralSherman
quality of turkish media is poor in comparisons to other countries by the way turkey has the highest number of columnists in the world that says something !!!! also media bosses have very strong influence on what is published, they usually use newspapers to undermine the government or their adversar...
wildTurkey
We are still waiting for several EU countries to capture wanted ASALA Armenian terorrists who committed murders againt Turkish citizens throughout Europe (including in Switzerland). It has been over 20 years and we are still waiting. Europeans do not have a right to speak of "delayed justice" or to ...
Semra
The openly hostile and anti-Turkey WSJ article only highlighted once again that Turkey needs to rely on its own intelligence when countering PKK terrorism (and the smuggelers that finance it)instead of on foreigners. In that regard, the WSJ article was a positive development and preparations in thi...
Semra
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
17 June 2013
Birth pains
13 June 2013
Social cracks
10 June 2013
Unfinished business
6 June 2013
Coming of age?
3 June 2013
Sorry seems to be the hardest word
30 May 2013
Juvenile justice system in the dock
27 May 2013
Conflicting data
23 May 2013
A top down approach
16 May 2013
A festering case
13 May 2013
Wrong target
9 May 2013
A heavy toll
6 May 2013
TESEV calls for security sector reforms
2 May 2013
Building bridges or drawing them?
29 April 2013
An İstanbul state of mind
25 April 2013
Europe in crisis
22 April 2013
Investing in early childhood
18 April 2013
Festering wounds
15 April 2013
Institutional violence
11 April 2013
Focus on children
8 April 2013
A confusing picture
1 April 2013
The other war
28 March 2013
The limits of solidarity
25 March 2013
Nurturing hope
21 March 2013
Work in progress
18 March 2013
UN pledge to fight violence against women
14 March 2013
Humanitarian crisis
11 March 2013
Talking peace
7 March 2013
'Enough is enough'
4 March 2013
On liberals and taking sides
28 February 2013
A heavy cost
25 February 2013
Demonstrating intent
21 February 2013
Child protection
18 February 2013
We are what we eat
14 February 2013
Yes without ‘but'
11 February 2013
Re-energizing the EU project
7 February 2013
A bygone era?
4 February 2013
A lack of determination
31 January 2013
Slower demographic expansion
28 January 2013
Failure to deliver
24 January 2013
Hate speech, hate crimes?
21 January 2013
What kind of human capital?
17 January 2013
Justice not served
14 January 2013
Combating rape
10 January 2013
Hope springs
7 January 2013
Gun control
3 January 2013
What prospects are there for change?
31 December 2012
Identities in flux
27 December 2012
A year on
24 December 2012
Global trends, local trends
20 December 2012
Monitoring education
17 December 2012
Taraf shockwaves
13 December 2012
Lost years
10 December 2012
Statistics and real lives
6 December 2012
Ruling by controversy
3 December 2012
Let’s talk about safe sex
29 November 2012
Zero tolerance?
26 November 2012
Below the surface
22 November 2012
Plenty more to be done
19 November 2012
Crisis ended, for now
12 November 2012
Disconnect
8 November 2012
Shifting demographics
5 November 2012
The world will be watching
1 November 2012
A perfect storm
29 October 2012
The great divide
22 October 2012
A gloomy picture
18 October 2012
Media, politics and women
15 October 2012
Tackling violence in the army
11 October 2012
Defending the rights of the girl child
4 October 2012
Confirming trends
1 October 2012
Animal charm
27 September 2012
Partly free
24 September 2012
Shifting power
20 September 2012
From the ground up
17 September 2012
The next education debate
13 September 2012
Journalists on trial
10 September 2012
Stop the clock!
6 September 2012
Hostile environment
3 September 2012
We are what we eat
30 August 2012
School burden
27 August 2012
No rape is legitimate
23 August 2012
After Gaziantep
16 August 2012
Déjà vu
13 August 2012
Up… and down
9 August 2012
Student rules
6 August 2012
Inside out, outside in
2 August 2012
Cause and effect
30 July 2012
Self-inflicted wounds
26 July 2012
On morality and maturity
23 July 2012
Down memory lane
19 July 2012
Olympic dreams
12 July 2012
Confusing signals
9 July 2012
Child policies under scrutiny
5 July 2012
Lightning speed
2 July 2012
Pieces of a jigsaw
28 June 2012
Selective change
25 June 2012
Handling it wrong, consistently
21 June 2012
Cycle of violence
18 June 2012
Prison tragedy
14 June 2012
Without consent
11 June 2012
Guilty until proven innocent
...
Bloggers