Pamuk’s Museum: closure for his magnificent novel
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
23 May 2013 Thursday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 29 April 2012, Sunday 0 0 0 0
YAVUZ BAYDAR
y.baydar@todayszaman.com

Pamuk’s Museum: closure for his magnificent novel

After I read my second-favorite novel by Orhan Pamuk, “Snow” (surpassed in my mind by his masterpiece, “The Black Book”), I had always carried the hope -- which I never mentioned to him in our encounters -- that he would one day open a museum on Kars -- the city -- in Kars.

He had obviously had the idea of a museum for a long time. As I strolled the narrow, weary streets of the Çukurcuma district in İstanbul on Friday evening, I felt that he had filled a huge blank in the City of All Cities by opening his meticulously planned Museum of Innocence -- situated, modestly but visibly, in a corner near a cul-de-sac.

It completes his latest project in a way, the novel of the same name. Almost 600 pages long, “The Museum of Innocence” has been informing the world ever since 2008 of the story of Kemal and Füsun. It can now be found in 60 languages. Hidden in the profound, obsessive love story is the life of İstanbul’s lost dreams, melancholia and hopes, from the 1950s through 2000.

Somehow, Pamuk was unable to publish the novel and launch the museum simultaneously. But, at the end of the process, I met a very happy author on Friday evening, satisfied that even those who had not read the text would now be able to see “lives that have been lived.”

The interior is overwhelming, to say the least. Spread across three floors, it is divided into 83 vitrines -- “showcases” -- just as the book is. They are filled with objects related to the book -- keys, lamps, watches, postcards, restaurant receipts, glasses of rakı, tiny portraits, ID cards and Pamuk’s handwritten sketches of the initial pages of the novel. To me, the most impressive part is at the entrance: In a huge showcase covering the wall, there are thousands of cigarette butts, the ones picked up by Kemal. Under almost each and every one of them, visitors can read -- again -- Pamuk’s comments in his own handwriting.

The museum is not only a must-see for everybody, but it also opens the door to a brand-new concept for artists, or anyone interested in preserving individual stories in history. It helps us all to cherish our choices -- however ordinary they may seem at times -- as filled with profound meanings, as they awaken others to our realities.

Pamuk’s recently published article in the Guardian, “Modest Manifesto,” therefore, must be read carefully and taken as a strong source of inspiration. Here are some excerpts:

“In my childhood, there were very few museums in İstanbul. Most of them were simply preserved historical monuments or -- quite rare outside the western world -- they were places with an air of the government office about them.”

“Museums should explore and uncover the universe and humanity of the new and modern man emerging especially from increasingly wealthy non-western nations. The aim of big, state-sponsored museums, on the other hand, is to represent the state. This is neither a good nor an innocent objective.”

“These institutions [museums], now national symbols, have presented the story of a nation -- in other words, history -- as much more important than the stories of individuals. This is unfortunate: The stories of individuals are much better suited to displaying the depths of our humanity.”

“We are sick and tired of museums that try to construct historical narratives of a society, community, team, nation, state, people, company or species. We all know that the ordinary, everyday stories of individuals are richer, more humane and much more joyful than the stories of colossal cultures.”

“Demonstrating the wealth of Chinese, Indian, Mexican, Iranian or Turkish history and culture is not an issue ... The real challenge is to use museums to tell, with the same brilliance, depth and power, the stories of the individual human beings living in these countries.”

“It is imperative that museums become smaller, more individualistic and cheaper. This is the only way that they will ever tell stories on a human scale. Big museums with their wide doors call upon us to forget our humanity and embrace the state and its human masses.”

“If objects are not uprooted from their environs and their streets, but are situated with care and ingenuity in their own natural homes, they will already portray their own stories.”

My space is limited, so those who are interested in the entire manifesto, translated by Ekin Oklap, should visit the Guardian website:

www.guardian.co.uk/artanddesign/2012/apr/20/orhan-pamuk-make-museums-much-smaller?newsfeed=true

Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
23 May 2013
And the winner is…
21 May 2013
Destructive obsession with news control
19 May 2013
Building bridges in Los Angeles
16 May 2013
Driving each other to the edge
14 May 2013
Between anger and deception
12 May 2013
Morally right, but…
9 May 2013
Withdrawal welcome as challenges mount
7 May 2013
Things get complicated
5 May 2013
Syria: ‘The worst is yet to come'
2 May 2013
Priority: democracy or peace?
30 April 2013
Human catastrophe at our doorsteps
28 April 2013
Jazz all over İstanbul tomorrow
25 April 2013
‘Point of no return'
23 April 2013
Glasnost, Kurds, Armenians, 1915
21 April 2013
Not unlikely: CHP's ‘modernists' may cop out
18 April 2013
Finally, an awakening
16 April 2013
Prime minister and the piano player
14 April 2013
‘So what?'
11 April 2013
The long-distance handshake
9 April 2013
Despite doubts, PKK much closer to withdrawal
7 April 2013
Deadlock clears way to destination
4 April 2013
Doors open for PKK pull-out
2 April 2013
Negative selection
31 March 2013
Escalation under way
28 March 2013
Which one is it: division or solution?
26 March 2013
Which is tougher: reactivating EU or race against time?
24 March 2013
At last, back to regional logic
21 March 2013
Turkey's Kurdish spring: historic day full of hope, doubts
19 March 2013
Milliyet daily a lame duck, as media crisis deepens
17 March 2013
Nonsensical stay-away
14 March 2013
Between the island, mountains and the capital
12 March 2013
Crisis at a key newspaper
10 March 2013
Between mind-reading and realism
7 March 2013
Uludere: cover-up
5 March 2013
If Iraq is being pulled in …
3 March 2013
Samaras stuns Erdoğan
28 February 2013
Hard drives cry for action
26 February 2013
Merkel's visit marks a turn
24 February 2013
Organizing the caravan which moves
21 February 2013
Time to stop engineering religion
19 February 2013
To protect a global brand
17 February 2013
Three challenges for Obama
14 February 2013
Foxes strike back, set for trouble
12 February 2013
Will Erdoğan also hold hands in Uludere?
10 February 2013
Erdoğan's new way
7 February 2013
BDP, as usual, unaware of momentum
5 February 2013
A cautious race against time
3 February 2013
Turkey's left still obsessed with culture of violence
31 January 2013
Erdoğan shifts gears, pushes agenda further
29 January 2013
Doomed to be torn within
27 January 2013
Towards the Shanghai Five
24 January 2013
The ‘shadow state' unfolding
22 January 2013
Undue confusion, unnecessary tension
20 January 2013
For Birand
17 January 2013
After the funerals, a ground more solid
15 January 2013
Today's Zaman: six years of intense coverage
13 January 2013
South by southwest
10 January 2013
Before a farewell to arms
8 January 2013
Still under hypnosis, against each other
6 January 2013
‘Number 10 is missing from the team'
3 January 2013
Delays of the Turkish mind
1 January 2013
Back to basics
30 December 2012
Five conclusions of the past year
27 December 2012
2012 -- a year hijacked by Uludere's ghosts
25 December 2012
In politics for public interest, a year of disappointment
23 December 2012
Towards a Maliki-Assad alliance
20 December 2012
‘Abolish constitution and proceed’
18 December 2012
Will Turkey walk out on the EU?
16 December 2012
Earthquake at Taraf -- a new wound for journalism
13 December 2012
Inventory of official looting and shame
11 December 2012
Where Preston has it wrong and where he falls short
9 December 2012
Reset with the visa
6 December 2012
State of mental deficit
4 December 2012
Much ado about something?
2 December 2012
Unpredictables: Morsi and Netanyahu
29 November 2012
Like a bad joke
27 November 2012
Magnificent times
25 November 2012
Spinning the wheel
22 November 2012
General’s right to remain silent
20 November 2012
Bitter lesson for Obama
18 November 2012
It is over, but not really
15 November 2012
Erdoğan-Gül divide
13 November 2012
‘Living Together’ under capital punishment
11 November 2012
Viral injection into Ergenekon
8 November 2012
Four years of opportunities
6 November 2012
CPJ’s critical shortcoming
4 November 2012
Beware of the image
1 November 2012
AKP at crossroads: the historic paradox
30 October 2012
Threshold of endurance
28 October 2012
October 29 and the tremulous republic
23 October 2012
‘Search mode’ or negotiations?
21 October 2012
Another gloomy report
18 October 2012
Two days in Cairo, talking media
16 October 2012
Gül’s veto -- or not
14 October 2012
Positive agenda: visa-free travel
11 October 2012
Non-progress report
9 October 2012
Time to revisit our foreign policy
7 October 2012
In Houston, a celebration
4 October 2012
Actors on display
2 October 2012
Filling in the blanks
...