What credit rating agencies don't see in Turkey
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
24 May 2013 Friday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 20 April 2012, Friday 7 0 0 0
HAKAN TAŞÇI
h.tasci@todayszaman.com

What credit rating agencies don't see in Turkey

There is always an excuse when it comes to Turkey's credit rating. Once it was political instability, then the elections, then the European crisis, then a closure case and now the current account deficit (CAD). But in all those years, Turkey managed to have high growth rates and maintain highly dynamic strong domestic demand and double-digit expansions in exports. In the meantime, suffering countries in Europe still have higher credit ratings than Turkey. While Turkey has a BBB- rating from Standard and Poor's today, Spain has an A- and Italy and Ireland have a BBB+. Until recently, Greece's credit rating was better than Turkey. The story is no different if you consider Fitch's, or Moody's. Despite 4 percent growth expectations, a less than 40 percent debt-to-gross domestic product (GDP) ratio, a fiscally very conservative budget, and political stability, Turkey is still not considered to be an “investable” country.

Someone may come up very good reasons for this by considering the quite sophisticated computation methods of these agencies and other types of leverage, like EU membership, for example. But this is more psychological than computational. They cannot adapt themselves to the new Turkey and the highly flexible, pro-business and solution-based state of economic management in Turkey. But, luckily, international investors do not think like credit rating agencies. That is why Turkish banks are getting quite good commercial loans at pretty low interest rates from international markets to finance domestic demand. A number of international firms operating in Turkey also tell the same story. Some 7,500 new international firms were established in Turkey over the last two years. Foreign direct investment (FDI) has also shown the same kind of signals over the last two years. What are we talking about when we say “new Turkey”? This is not a political statement, nor an ideological one. This is purely related to effective government and the problem solving capacity of elected officials, as well as a highly dynamic and effective civil society engaging with the policy makers instead of lobbying for their own interests.

I would like to give a concrete example to explain what I am trying to say here. If you listen carefully, you'll hear Economy Minister Zafer Çağlayan talking about a new investment incentive scheme to be implemented over the next couple of years, including very generous offers for strategic international investments, high value-added goods production and literally tax-free investment opportunities for low income parts of the country, especially in the Southeast.

This package is not giving money to investors, as was done before, resulting in unfinished investments in the Southeast. This program lowers the cost of doing business enormously to attract labor-intensive sectors to the region instead of sending them abroad to Egypt or China. So here is the first target. This package is trying to decrease income inequality through positive discrimination. As well as strategic, patent and innovation-based investments, high value-added products will also reap the benefits of tax-free investment opportunities no matter where they are located. Research and development investments are also in this category, which aims to restructure the value chain. Today, two-thirds of Turkish exports are low-to-mid value-added products, which is unsustainable in the long term. Rising exports and export-driven growth strategies are enough to graduate a country from the low income to medium income country class, but it is not enough to become a developed economy with over $20,000 per capita income. This second strategy targets high value-added export goods from one-third to two-thirds of exports and domestic production. The third component of this incentive scheme is to decrease the CAD by lowering the import dependency for energy, intermediate goods and services required in the industry. Hydropower projects and renewable energy investments are getting all sorts of incentives, while imported oil and gas-related power generation facilities are lacking this opportunity. Don't you think this is the right type of leadership after all?

In his three-day trip to the US, Çağlayan promoted this new package in three different states. The Texas Turkish American Chamber of Commerce (TTACC) organized a dinner to honor him in Houston. It was amazing to see 350 Texan businessmen showing up to listen to a Turkish minister on a cozy night, instead of having fun at home with their families. And in turn they managed to establish a direct flight to Houston from İstanbul. Once again TTACC showed that we need to have local grassroots organizations to increase the level of trade and investment. Hosting six business delegations in Texas and the surrounding states in three months' time, in partnership with the Turkish Confederation of Businessmen and Industrialists (TUSKON), is quite an accomplishment. Now we look forward to witnessing the concrete results of these efforts.

COMMENTS
yuksel insaat credit rating
zeynep koruturk
i like to have frnd from turkiya
Tota
dear erol, or shoud i say "dimitrios", the future belongs to turkey and not greece
dev
I do not like this approach to foreign organizations. If a foreign organization raises even the slightest critisism, they are either EVIL rasists or STUPID. They are never correct and often they appear to be part of a huge conspiracy against Turkey.
All foreigners are bad?
I am afraid that you, like many Turks, have confused the politeness of Westerners as a sign that they like and trust you. I am afraid your history and the actions of the AK government mean that it will be a long time before Turkey is seen as a reliable partner for anyone - Westerners, Arabs or Iran...
real business
This new direction is really quite astounding, and again another in a long string of hot air. You could see it coming. Several weeks ago, one of the highest value-added textile companies Turkey has, Yeşim, announced plans to invest $350 million in a new plant in Dagestan. Instead of convincing oth...
I.M. Straman
Dear Sir, perhaps these institutions are reading the continuing damning reports on the situation of education in Turkey and draw a few conclusions for the future. Can't blame them, really.
erol
Click here to read all user comments
Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
25 December 2012
Consumption trends in Turkish economy
18 December 2012
Tough fiscal cliff talks
11 December 2012
A transactional relationship: Russia and Turkey
10 December 2012
Infrastructure development key for next decade's growth
20 November 2012
Central bank throws the ball to government
13 November 2012
The next choice: compromise or the fiscal cliff
6 November 2012
The wonders of shale gas
23 October 2012
We shall vote for the US president
16 October 2012
Price wars and the Nobel laureates
9 October 2012
How to re-energize the industrialists
2 October 2012
Magic potion for Turkish economy
25 September 2012
Investing in the next big thing
11 September 2012
Who is the right candidate for the economy: Obama or Romney?
4 September 2012
Wither the US-Turkey economic partnership
28 August 2012
How to measure the value of entrepreneurship?
14 August 2012
Good news from the current account deficit front
7 August 2012
Weakening euro no good for Turkey
31 July 2012
Financial reforms: four years after Lehman Brothers
24 July 2012
Centralized exams and the quality of education
17 July 2012
2012 critical for Turkish economy
10 July 2012
Why don't women work in Turkey?
8 June 2012
Turkish trade's center of gravity shifting in TUSKON bridges
5 June 2012
Soft landing strategy is working, how about reforms?
29 May 2012
Turkish trade with Arab Spring countries flourishing
22 May 2012
The real challenge for the Turkish economy
15 May 2012
Turkish-American partnership 2.0
1 May 2012
A year on with the new Central Bank of Turkey governor
24 April 2012
Who will save Europe? Back to multilateralism
20 April 2012
What credit rating agencies don't see in Turkey
10 April 2012
‘Turkey’s time has come’
3 April 2012
Is this a good time to invest in US real estate?
27 March 2012
Innovation in China and lessons for Turkey
20 March 2012
Turkey will shape the future of the region
6 March 2012
Ben Bernanke’s changing views, a confused IMF and Turkey’s interest rate hawks
28 February 2012
G20 is more relevant than ever
24 February 2012
The world in 2050
14 February 2012
Kayseri, the home of entrepreneurs
7 February 2012
Going beyond lobbying
31 January 2012
IMF wary of latest developments in Turkish economy
17 January 2012
Managing expectations is the trick
10 January 2012
Turkish economy is in good hands
20 December 2011
European crisis and Turkey's bumpy accession process
13 December 2011
Can Turkey control credit expansion and inflation with high growth?
6 December 2011
The story of young sharks and a whale
29 November 2011
Ratings of credit rating agencies downgraded to junk
22 November 2011
What would be the role of the European Central Bank?
15 November 2011
Can Europe swallow its own bitter medicine?
1 November 2011
The economics of political transformation in Arab states
25 October 2011
Another chicken and egg problem: oil prices vs. growth
21 October 2011
Turkey implements economic programs Obama had in mind for US
4 October 2011
Can state-sponsored patents generate innovation?
27 September 2011
Who will tell the truth?
20 September 2011
Developing a Turkish-American economic partnership
13 September 2011
Chobani and a proposal for the upcoming US-Turkey Business Council
6 September 2011
How will Israeli-Turkish tension affect economic cooperation?
23 August 2011
Entrepreneurship or go where the action is
16 August 2011
Ramadan, Somalia, and economics
14 August 2011
How will Turkey benefit from the recent turmoil?
9 August 2011
What’s more worrying than a credit rating downgrade?
26 July 2011
Dangerous game: political wrangling on debt ceiling
12 July 2011
Interest rate hike? Not an urgent task
5 July 2011
The story of seven fat cows being eaten by seven skinny ones
7 June 2011
Partisan politics in the US and rocky road ahead
31 May 2011
Vulnerable growth and to-do list for post-election period
24 May 2011
Stalemate in Doha Rounds and the fear of China
10 May 2011
TUSKON and three key elements of sustainable development
3 May 2011
Do people really not become happier as Turkey grows wealthier?
20 April 2011
The next IMF head and the changing dynamics of int’l economic policy making
13 April 2011
IMF sides with central bank against bankers in Turkey
6 April 2011
Turkish contribution to world peace
30 March 2011
Dying industries in the Internet age
16 March 2011
The story of cities in this urbanization era
8 March 2011
A tough year ahead
22 February 2011
Success stories in US-Turkish economic partnerships
15 February 2011
The US-Turkey Business Council
8 February 2011
Food prices, inflation, the Fed and Egypt
1 February 2011
Targeting the current account deficit
25 January 2011
China’s way and US confusion
11 January 2011
Wall Street government: Who holds the bag?
4 January 2011
The honeymoon is over: prospects for the Turkish economy in 2011
28 December 2010
Soccer in Turkey as a source of social cohesion
22 December 2010
Unconventional wisdom of Turkish Central Bank
14 December 2010
Privatization: A bullish view on Turkey
7 December 2010
Anatolian business clusters: the new center of gravity in Turkey
30 November 2010
Neglected domain in US-Turkish relations
23 November 2010
Is NATO ready for a global century?
16 November 2010
G-20: sovereignty vs. global governance
9 November 2010
Rowing against the tide: US-Turkey bilateral trade
...