What do the Alevis want?
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
18 May 2013 Saturday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 01 December 2011, Thursday 0 0 0 0
HÜSEYİN GÜLERCE
h.gulerce@todayszaman.com

What do the Alevis want?

In my last column I tried to find an answer to the question “Why could the Alevis not give up on the CHP?” And when I ask why the Alevis could not give up on the Republican People’s Party (CHP), I am not saying I am uncomfortable with them voting for the CHP and that they should support other parties -- like the Justice and Development Party (AK Party). I am not concerned about the political preferences of the Alevis.

I am concerned about the overall situation of the Alevis, their problems and their priorities. I am concerned about how the Alevi issue will be resolved. Therefore, the real matter is the resolution of the Alevi issue, which is seated deeper than the Kurdish problem. Let me go beyond and say this: When referring to Dersim and the massacre committed against the residents of Dersim -- yes, a massacre -- I find revengeful acts and responses pretty dangerous. Let us face our history. However, it would not be any good to exploit the past’s pains and sufferings and create polarizations out of these pains. And this will be no good for the country as well. Quite the contrary, the problem grows bigger, the conflict gets deeper and we will have to leave peace, dialogue and conciliation to another century.

Let us admit this: Quite rightly, the Alevi citizens are experiencing a problem of trust. They were intimidated and persecuted during the Ottoman and republican eras. Justice should be done to them; they should be treated with mercy and tolerance. I believe that Yavuz Sultan Selim would have sought a different way had he predicted what would happen in Dersim and appreciate the gravity of the current problem that the present generations have to deal with.

We should be able to take a look at the future instead of being stuck in the past; and we should be able to construct a social peace project in the name of coexistence in peace and harmony.

How could we do this? Of course, a new civilian constitution and the adoption of new bills is important. But more important than this is overcoming the prejudices and obsessions between the Sunnis and Alevis. This requires good faith and sincere efforts. Everybody should express themselves on this matter. Above all, we should go back to the fact that we are all humans. Regardless of our religious belief, sect or faith, we are human beings first. And on this soil, on this planet, we would like to live as humans. Yes, we need a transformation in democratic mentality and a principle of equal citizenship. But we cannot do things right without seeing each other as humans and appreciating the value of a human being. Otherwise, we would be trapped by misleading one another, fake dialogues and materialistic approaches.

Appreciating the human being requires respect for each other. This means respect for the ideas, views and lives of others. Of course, we cannot agree with all the views of others. There might be many areas of disagreement as well. But we also have a large sphere that we could share and agree on. The first step is to be able to listen to each other, to understand each other and to reach a level of reconciliation.

We need to overcome the issue of the lack of confidence and trust between different social groups in this country, not only the one between Sunnis and Alevis. Turkey cannot resolve the Alevi issue or the Kurdish issue without normalization. I could rephrase this as follows: Turkey cannot be democratic without resolving the Alevi issue and the Kurdish problem; and it cannot attain domestic peace. We need a comprehensive climate of dialogue and tolerance in society.

Obviously, the Alevis conclude that they are under threat in the predominantly Sunni Turkey. They want to have trust and faith in the rulers. The AK Party and the political administration need to take action to address this sentiment. Even though I am not questioning good faith, I should underline that sometimes we experience disturbing actions and discourses that bother all of our Alevi peoples.

In a democratic Turkey, where freedom of expression, religious freedom and the rule of law are secured, political preferences will be free. I believe wholeheartedly that Turkey is on this track.

Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
9 May 2013
Responses to concerns and worries
7 May 2013
Inevitable direction: Plan C
30 April 2013
Process of caution and vigilance
4 April 2013
What will the wise men do?
28 March 2013
Let's try peace, shall we?
26 March 2013
Wise men board a must?
19 March 2013
New Ergenekon scenarios
14 March 2013
Headscarved penguin
12 March 2013
What happens to the AK Party if Öcalan is released?
7 March 2013
Brainstorming on the leaked minutes
5 March 2013
What will be the result of the negotiations?
28 February 2013
Games begin to muddy process
26 February 2013
What if they don't listen to Öcalan?
21 February 2013
I am a nationalist
19 February 2013
What's happening in Sinop, Samsun?
15 February 2013
Is the prime minister being political or sincere?
12 February 2013
Prime minister's visit to Saygun
5 February 2013
Dialogue is not a jacket
1 February 2013
Presidential system on the horizon
30 January 2013
Shock waves not restricted to the CHP
11 January 2013
Paris assassinations and the İmralı processes
14 December 2012
A Muslim society no impediment to democracy
2 December 2012
Ergenekon is just the means…
20 November 2012
Gaza’s heavenly children
15 November 2012
Private university prep courses, opposition and TOBB
4 November 2012
Is it solely about Erdoğan and Gül?
23 October 2012
Does this mean there will be no new constitution?
19 October 2012
Do new things really happen in Ankara?
16 October 2012
Tragedy in Western Thrace
11 October 2012
On terrorism and crying
10 October 2012
Possibility of war, Iran and NATO
25 September 2012
The whole point is to get rid of the AK Party
21 September 2012
Will terrorism end? And other questions
19 September 2012
Traces of assassinations: from Özal to Erdoğan
14 September 2012
Which button was hit in Libya?
12 September 2012
TSK statements shed light on the truth
30 August 2012
Aug. 30, Ergenekon and our army
15 August 2012
Was Aygün really kidnapped by the PKK?
10 August 2012
You should ask the PKK
7 August 2012
A new era in government-TSK relations
31 July 2012
New foreign policy in new Turkey
26 July 2012
Strategic depth and romanticism
19 July 2012
Conservatism: What we were; what have we become?
17 July 2012
HAS Party merger and beyond
12 July 2012
How was our jet downed, really?
10 July 2012
Release of deputies under detention
5 July 2012
They will not be able to make football an arena for enmity
3 July 2012
What really happened with specially authorized courts?
28 June 2012
Do it, but listen first
26 June 2012
Syria trap
21 June 2012
Before entering Kandil
19 June 2012
Hopes for peace and Dağlıca attack
7 June 2012
The situation is now clear, but …
5 June 2012
Democracy, not ‘The community,’ will be undermined
31 May 2012
New trap for the AK Party?
29 May 2012
Things that dark sunglasses hide
24 May 2012
Uludere in all its urgency…
22 May 2012
Why do we need to ride on the EU bid wave?
15 May 2012
Is a semi-presidential system on the horizon?
8 May 2012
Good news from Prophet’s Way
3 May 2012
A Silivri trap for the AK Party?
1 May 2012
Trucks in Taksim and Susurluk
26 April 2012
No, you won’t be able to destroy and eliminate it
19 April 2012
The real reason behind Feb. 28
17 April 2012
The season for birds to sing…
15 April 2012
‘What, İbrahim, can be bad about this?’
10 April 2012
Could there be an army that has its officers killed?
5 April 2012
A Sept. 12 coup for Ergenekon supporters…
3 April 2012
Quran, the AK Party and the MHP
29 March 2012
Beware: it is a plot within a plot
27 March 2012
The closure of Özgür Gündem
22 March 2012
Why does Evren still think so?
20 March 2012
My eyes are set on shores far more alluring than your polemics
13 March 2012
ÇEV, Interpol, Sabancı murder…
6 March 2012
The new constitution has a bold owner
28 February 2012
Feb. 28 from a different angle
23 February 2012
Why is there such interest in ‘Fetih 1453’?
16 February 2012
Those who infiltrate the state
15 February 2012
Sabotage: government-Gülen movement relations
9 February 2012
MİT, the judiciary and the new constitution
7 February 2012
Islamic faction and democracy
2 February 2012
Don't treat TSK and junta as the same
26 January 2012
Diyarbakır skulls are proof of our sorrows
24 January 2012
As the mystery on the east of the Euphrates is resolved
17 January 2012
Thank you, Vice Adm. Sağdıç
12 January 2012
Greatest trick of pro-Ergenekon figures
10 January 2012
Saving Başbuğ…
5 January 2012
Why was the Uludere plot devised?
3 January 2012
Who devised the Uludere plot?
27 December 2011
Ergenekon, Sledgehammer, Sivas, Maraş…
22 December 2011
Is it possible to cover up the Ergenekon case?
20 December 2011
Will a new constitution be written?
15 December 2011
Is it really all that great that we are not yet in the EU?
13 December 2011
Letter from Van...
8 December 2011
The AK Party's match-fixing test
6 December 2011
The Sunnis' responsibility on the Alevi issue
1 December 2011
What do the Alevis want?
29 November 2011
Why the Alevis just cannot give up on the CHP?
22 November 2011
Dersim and the derailment of tutelage
17 November 2011
Ergenekon case rattles PKK
...