The meaning of Mrs. Güzel’s ‘V’ sign
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
24 May 2013 Friday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 16 November 2011, Wednesday 0 0 0 0
FATMA DİŞLİ ZIBAK
f.zibak@todayszaman.com

The meaning of Mrs. Güzel’s ‘V’ sign

Siti Güzel, the mother of the man who hijacked a passenger ferry last week but was killed before he could detonate explosives reported to have been strapped to his body, made a victory sign following the death of her son.

 Mensur Güzel, a Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) terrorist, was killed on Saturday in a pre-dawn operation to rescue more than 20 passengers and crewmembers whom he had held hostage for 12 hours on board a high-speed ferry near İstanbul. It was very strange for a mother to make such a gesture just after losing her son -- something which many believe needs to be examined to get an understanding about how any mother with a compassionate heart could make a “V” sign after losing a son in violent circumstances.

Bugün’s Ahmet Taşgetiren is one of those who failed to understand the meaning of the gesture by Güzel’s mother. “What was that sign for? Was it because your son wrapped explosives around himself? Was it because your son got on that ferry and sacrificed his life for ‘leader [of the PKK, Abdullah] Öcalan’? Was it because he failed in his attempt to carry out a terrorist attack and lost his life? What was that ‘V’ sign for? You are a mother. How can the heart of a mother be so politicized? What if your son had set off the explosives wrapped around his body, blown up the ferry and killed the mothers, fathers and children on the ferry? Would you still have made the ‘V’ sign?” asks Taşgetiren. He says he cannot believe the idea to make the ‘V’ sign belonged solely to Mrs. Güzel as he cannot imagine a mother in such a position just after losing her son. Taşgetiren says that if a mother who had not seen her son for four years found out he had wrapped explosives around himself and hijacked a ferry, she would do her best to stop her son, that she would never tell him to sacrifice his life for the “leader.” “Oh Siti Ana [Mrs. Güzel], what did they do to you? What did they do to your son Mensur? Is there anyone in this world who cries for Mensur as much as you do?” asks Taşgetiren.

Radikal’s Eyüp Can, who opened the meaning of Mrs. Güzel “V” sign up to debate, says he has received dozens of letters from his readers on the issue. He thinks questioning and trying to understand the meaning of this gesture is of crucial importance for an end to the cycle of violence in this country. Sharing excerpts from readers’ letters, Can quotes one reader going by the name Fatih: “Let me tell you the meaning of that sign. It means ‘I want peace.’ It is the sign of all Kurdish mothers.” Another reader, Cem Somel, likens Mrs. Güzel’s reaction to that of families of martyred soldiers who say, “Long live our homeland,” in the wake of the loss of their sons. He says it is difficult for a mother to accept that her son’s death was in vain, so she seeks some solace in making a “V” sign to mean that her son died for an important cause.

Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
19 May 2013
Was Erdoğan's visit to the US fruitful?
5 May 2013
Peace on the horizon
14 April 2013
Reflections on the wise men commission
12 April 2013
The CHP and the settlement process
7 April 2013
Role of wise men commission
24 March 2013
Israel's apology
10 March 2013
Peace process on track
24 February 2013
Prospects for peace
17 February 2013
THY debate
27 January 2013
Reflections on the Cabinet reshuffle
6 January 2013
Hopes and PKK talks
23 December 2012
Controversy on separation of powers
16 December 2012
Controversial ATK report
25 November 2012
Nov. 24 and unappointed teachers
16 November 2012
BDP and the hunger strike
15 November 2012
Hunger strike conundrum
14 November 2012
Is Erdoğan serious?
13 November 2012
Reinstatement of capital punishment
12 November 2012
Presidential system
11 November 2012
Secret witness debate
28 October 2012
Democracy, republic reconciliation
21 October 2012
Kavakçı and Feb. 28
7 October 2012
Media's regret
5 October 2012
The meaning of the motion
4 October 2012
War with Syria?
3 October 2012
Gül-Erdoğan conflict?
2 October 2012
President Gül’s messages
1 October 2012
Erdoğan’s speech
2 September 2012
Erdoğan's disappointment
12 August 2012
Joy of Olympic success
29 July 2012
Police's honor
15 July 2012
AK Party-HAS Party merger
1 July 2012
A promising meeting
17 June 2012
Zana’s remarks
13 June 2012
A historic but belated move
3 June 2012
Abortion debate
20 May 2012
A different May 19
22 April 2012
YGS results and prejudices
8 April 2012
Confronting the Sept. 12 coup
25 March 2012
Turkey’s new anti-terrorism strategy
11 March 2012
Kurdish issue and the new constitution
4 March 2012
4+4+4 controversy
19 February 2012
Chaotic days for CHP
12 February 2012
Unusual days for Turkey
22 January 2012
Erdoğan's health
15 January 2012
May 19 debate
25 December 2011
Farewell to Aydın Menderes
19 December 2011
AK Party and next president
18 December 2011
The problem with France
16 December 2011
Rigging in ratings
15 December 2011
2014 scenarios
14 December 2011
An unnerving amendment
13 December 2011
Cübbeli’s case
12 December 2011
The fate of match-fixers
11 December 2011
Will violence against women ever end?
9 December 2011
Talk of AK Party division unrealistic, baseless
8 December 2011
Rift or asset of democracy?
7 December 2011
Risks for AK Party
6 December 2011
Turkish football’s test with match-fixing
5 December 2011
Fate of Turkish football
2 December 2011
Revisiting Dersim and Turkish history
1 December 2011
Gül’s choice
30 November 2011
Endless debate on Dersim
29 November 2011
President’s responsibility
28 November 2011
Confronting official history
27 November 2011
Miserable case of the CHP
25 November 2011
Kılıçdaroğlu’s failure in Dersim case
24 November 2011
Erdoğan’s apology
23 November 2011
Some happy, some still disappointed
22 November 2011
Is a new constitution so far away?
21 November 2011
Dim future for Kılıçdaroğlu
20 November 2011
The desperate case of the CHP
18 November 2011
The CHP’s test over the Dersim massacre
17 November 2011
The AK Party and claims of civilian tutelage
16 November 2011
The meaning of Mrs. Güzel’s ‘V’ sign
15 November 2011
Attacks on friendship
14 November 2011
Death or murder?
13 November 2011
Life after the earthquakes
9 November 2011
KCK operations: helping or hurting?
4 November 2011
KCK arrests highlight need for anti-terror law amendment
3 November 2011
KCK arrests
2 November 2011
A wounded psyche
1 November 2011
Controversial detentions
31 October 2011
Is the republic being weakened?
30 October 2011
Turkey debates Republic Day cancellations
28 October 2011
Lessons to take from the Van quake
27 October 2011
Murder network
26 October 2011
Racism knows no limits
25 October 2011
Scent of brotherhood
24 October 2011
Uniting over pain
23 October 2011
Gaddafi’s tragic end
21 October 2011
Why is Turkey failing to fight terrorism?
20 October 2011
Enough of violence
19 October 2011
Reflections on swap deal
18 October 2011
Wall Street protests
17 October 2011
Is peace far away?
16 October 2011
A fresh look at Golden Orange
14 October 2011
Why is the AK Party reluctant to address the headscarf ban?
13 October 2011
Kılıçdaroğlu’s credibility
12 October 2011
Is Atalay a mole?
...