Warm hearts and clear minds in Iceland
 
 
  |  
  |  
  |  
  |  
RSS
  |  
  |  
  |  
20 June 2013 Thursday
 
 
 
 
 
 
Columnists 13 May 2010, Thursday 0 0 0 0
MUHAMMED ÇETİN
cetin.m@todayszaman.com

Warm hearts and clear minds in Iceland

For just over a week I have been giving lectures and attending workshops on intercultural dialog and civic service ethics in Baltic and Scandinavian countries, and I am heartened by the level of interest and feedback from European academics and statesmen.
It is striking how very knowledgeable the academics and specialists on Turkey are in Denmark, Sweden, Norway and Iceland and how closely they follow developments in Turkey. To my further delight, they lack the characteristic arrogance of the modern academic, demonstrating instead the humility of the true scholar. Some spoke openly of their spiritual search and how they have decided to follow the Sufi path.

Informed of my lecture topics, the president of Iceland, Olafur Ragnar Grimsson, gave me an audience. In the simply styled presidential mansion, the president offered me tea and freshly made pancakes. For one-and-a-half hours he asked me almost a dozen questions about my lecture topic and research interest. He was sincerely interested in alternative views and perspectives on my field of work, on intercultural dialog, issues related to Islam and Muslim integration in the contemporary world, especially in Europe.

President Grimsson asked why I had been asked to lecture about interfaith and intercultural dialog and how this had been received in the Scandinavian countries. He asked whether I could do the same in Muslim Arab countries, how that would be received by local Arab scholars and how non-Arabic speaking lecturers or scholars might be received in the Middle East or Arab contexts. He asked about the reason for the rise of young radicals in those countries and possible ways to appeal to their citizens, especially the younger generation. He expressed surprise that within the same period religion is declining in the European context but gaining prominence in the United States.

He also asked if events in Turkey resemble the efforts of the Christian right and religious groups to influence the courts in the US. He asked about the Turkish government's intent on the constitutional amendments, especially the amendments concerning the courts. From his own extensive knowledge of world politics, he gave examples of how the law and courts can be used to crush opposition. He gave examples from Texas, Mexico, Indonesia, Malaysia, Pakistan, India and Turkey of ways of eliminating opposition, with exact names and dates and cases going back to the 1940s.

President Grimsson noted that Turkey occupies an important place culturally and politically between West and East. He expressed surprise that in Turkey the state bureaucracy and some very high-powered businessmen are against EU accession. While he saw the bureaucracy's stance as understandable to a certain extent, he saw the businessmen's rejection as inexplicable.

He said that while Turkey can play a great role between East and West and in Europe culturally, the authorities in Turkey do not seem keen on taking that initiative. He argued that India is the best example of multicultural, plural democracy, while acknowledging its weaknesses and faults in some aspects. He pointed out that members of the Indian Sikh, Catholic and Muslim communities had been able to occupy influential positions such as that of prime minister and president, making India a great example of intercultural and interfaith representation.

He also asked about the Turkish community in Iceland and about their needs in terms of faith, education and successful integration. He asked about the cultural center established by people of Turkish origin living and working in Iceland.

Discussing economic corruption in Europe, broken marriages, single parenthood, drug abuse and a rising nationalist militancy, he noted that he does not accept the argument that European society is declining demographically He said the statistics and thus the claims are fallacious. He explained that many people in his country and in the Baltics have a different understanding of family and family leadership, and to compare their family structure with traditional Eastern models and values is misleading.

Hailing from a social science background himself and keen to learn more about the state, government, republican history and developments in Turkey, President Grimsson said he would read my own recently published book, “The Gulen Movement: Civic service without borders.” In line with his interest in the peaceful integration of minorities and dialogue, he also expressed approval of the title and approach of Jill Carroll's 2007 book “A Dialogue of Civilizations.”

President Grimsson's erudition and his willingness to read and inquire about other cultures and nations and benefit from their experience, combined with his straightforward and humble manner impressed me greatly. Issuing a heartfelt invitation to Turkey and with an exchange of good wishes, we left with an impression of a man who, while ruling a country, remains for and among the people.

Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
17 February 2011
Where have you been all these years?
10 February 2011
European security and Islamism: planks and splinters
3 February 2011
The lion’s share, the wolf’s fate and the Arab world
27 January 2011
Unsolved killings block peace and democracy in Turkey
20 January 2011
Civic engagement, success and the Gülen movement
6 January 2011
The media: setting the political or public agenda
30 December 2010
Alarmism: part of the pattern in Turkey
23 December 2010
Kurds and Turks: no singular solution
16 December 2010
Bags of ill will from the Turkish naval base
9 December 2010
Careless talk and the Turkey-Israel rapprochement
2 December 2010
The elite fights discrimination
25 November 2010
Elections, religion and the opposition parties in Turkey
11 November 2010
New candidate for ‘Guinness World Records’: warped justice
28 October 2010
February 28 scenes replayed with a cheap cast
21 October 2010
A long and dishonorable European tradition
14 October 2010
Infiltrating or contributing?
7 October 2010
Cutting through the fog over the Golden Horn: perspectives on Turkey
30 September 2010
Faith in the US: On the sleeve or on the Ground?
23 September 2010
The education boycott and pseudo-civil society in Turkey
16 September 2010
Fostering democratic character: cooperation or forced compliance?
9 September 2010
Referendum results: Who won and who lost?
2 September 2010
Parallels: the US and the Iraqis, Turkey and the Kurds
19 August 2010
PKK cease-fire: unmapped and unverifiable
12 August 2010
Civilian and military readiness after the referendum
5 August 2010
New Turkish generals and the greatest good
29 July 2010
Totalitarianism, complicity and Turkey’s future
22 July 2010
Crises and accountability: civil, military and judicial
15 July 2010
Democratic labor pains in Turkey
8 July 2010
Civil society, education and ‘masters’ in Turkey
1 July 2010
The Kurdish issue: trapped between two deep states
24 June 2010
Turkey: kill or cure?
17 June 2010
Above and beyond the law: no reform for the Turkish judiciary
10 June 2010
Role of civil society in Turkey’s judicial reform
3 June 2010
Diplomacy, diplomacy and diplomacy
27 May 2010
CHP: Institutionalization vs. personality politics
20 May 2010
To reform judiciary in Turkey
13 May 2010
Warm hearts and clear minds in Iceland
6 May 2010
Patterns, PKK attacks and polemical generals
29 April 2010
Ankara court attack: lone gunman or plot?
15 April 2010
The military and judiciary, secrets and lies
8 April 2010
Mouse, frog, plotters and judiciary in Turkey
1 April 2010
Constitutional reform, disinformation, opposition’s self-abasement
25 March 2010
Who can change the Turkish Constitution?
18 March 2010
Wanted: democratic opposition in Turkey
4 March 2010
Macbeth, the Turkish junta and foreign pundits
25 February 2010
Coups and plots: truth in Turkey
18 February 2010
Solipsism and idle threats from the Turkish deep state
11 February 2010
Junta, deep state, elections and interregnum
4 February 2010
Pre-emption and presumption: Blair and Turkish juntas
28 January 2010
Coups in Turkey: none so blind...
14 January 2010
Military-bureaucratic shadow falls over democratization in Turkey
7 January 2010
Turkey’s democratization knocks at junta’s bedroom door
31 December 2009
Harassing the press in Turkey
24 December 2009
Plots, assassinations and the madness of bureaucratic red herrings
13 December 2009
East and West Encounters: The Gülen movement or ‘hizmet’
3 December 2009
Resignation is not only for Germans
26 November 2009
Killing kids and justifying the junta’s actions
19 November 2009
Civil-military relations, ‘regime’ stability and democratization
12 November 2009
Testing times for Muslims, Americans and believers the world over
5 November 2009
Turkey from negarchy to democracy
29 October 2009
Concerning civilian-military relations
22 October 2009
Democratic consolidation and Turkey
15 October 2009
Elites: sustainers or underminers of democratization
8 October 2009
Turkey and the transition to democracy
1 October 2009
Kurds & journalists, real & symbolic
24 September 2009
Eid, autumn leaves, Ergenekon and freedom of speech
17 September 2009
On track with Kurdish-Turkish conflict resolution
10 September 2009
Reflections on the second report on Turkey
27 August 2009
Conflict resolution in the Southeast: a new kind of listening post
20 August 2009
Talking conflict resolution in southeast Turkey
13 August 2009
Torture: breaking the breaking wheel
6 August 2009
The paradox of judicial independence and accountability
30 July 2009
Routes to self-destruction
23 July 2009
Untouchables’ grasp on our freedoms
16 July 2009
Knowledge and accountability at home and abroad
9 July 2009
Infotainted infotainment
2 July 2009
The left does not do right in Turkey
25 June 2009
The unbearable lightness of media being
18 June 2009
Democracy: how to participate and how not to
11 June 2009
Obama’s olive branch
4 June 2009
Post-Potsdam conference reflections
28 May 2009
Could all great Neptune’s ocean cleanse the blood from their hands?
21 May 2009
Polemical journalism and its consequences
14 May 2009
The robber and the merchant
7 May 2009
Prefabricated findings in Washington
30 April 2009
Economic, social crises and disintegration
16 April 2009
Tales from my country (3): Nasreddin Hodja, the bold thief and the US excuse
9 April 2009
Tales from my country (2): roosters, grain and the Turkish people
2 April 2009
Tales from my country (1): Caesar or Sezer, the coup helper
26 March 2009
Deceit, betrayal and nihilism of coup makers and helpers
19 March 2009
Who is radical anyway?
12 March 2009
Censorship or freedom of the press in Turkey
26 February 2009
A run on our values
19 February 2009
The Turkey-Russia rapprochement and its implications
12 February 2009
Burn the flag + respect the flag = ‘false flag’ anyway
29 January 2009
How to be an Americanist
22 January 2009
President Obama’s inauguration, the great state and the deep state
15 January 2009
Iran, Israel, Europe and Russian leverage
8 January 2009
Israeli-Palestinian conflict and Tony Blair the savior
1 January 2009
Ahmadinejad’s Christmas message and forcing the hand of God
...
Bloggers